Senate Hearing Sparks Debate Over Natural Rights

During a recent Senate hearing, a comparison was made between fundamental U.S. principles and Iranian doctrines in the context of President Donald Trump’s nominee for Secretary of State for Democracy, Human Rights, and Workers, Riley Burns. Senator Tim Kaine from Virginia spoke out against Burns’ remarks.

In his initial comments, Burns referenced Secretary of State Marco Rubio, asserting that the United States is founded on the principle that all individuals are created equal and that rights originate from a creator rather than the government. He emphasized the importance of democracy, human rights, and labor, insisting these concepts are integral to American identity.

However, Kaine, a practicing Catholic, found this perspective troubling. He remarked, “The claim that rights stem from a creator, not from government or laws, aligns with beliefs held by the Iranian regime,” which he described as a theocracy that persecutes various religious minorities under Shia law. “This notion that our rights aren’t derived from our laws or government is quite concerning,” he added.

Kaine acknowledged his strong belief in natural rights but noted that discussions in the committee might reveal significant differences in how various beliefs and religious traditions interpret these rights. Interestingly, while the Constitution doesn’t explicitly mention God or a creator, the Declaration of Independence does affirm that rights are endowed by a creator.

In response to Kaine’s comments, Bishop Robert Barron from Minnesota expressed his disagreement via a social media post, criticizing lawmakers for rejecting the idea that rights come from God. He argued, “If the government is the source of our rights, it can also take them away or alter them.” He expressed his disappointment that prominent politicians seem to overlook this crucial aspect of American governance.

Kaine’s office was contacted for a response, but there hasn’t been any immediate feedback.