Staten Island’s Secession Talk Resurfaces
Leaders from New York City’s Staten Island, the most conservative borough, are reviving a proposal to secede from the city. They express concerns that Staten Island may evolve into what they’re calling the “People’s Republic of Mamdani.”
State Senator Andrew Lanza argues that democratic socialists are vastly different from Staten Island’s community values, emphasizing that this time, the Democratic Party won’t back down. “I think the timing is just right for this,” he said, keen on pushing the proposal, which he has supported since 2008, to gain traction. He envisions Richmond County’s independence coming just in time for the 250th anniversary of the United States next year.
Despite his previous efforts, Lanza notes that the rest of New York City leans heavily left, potentially providing a reason for Democrats to support separating Staten Island, known for its moderate and Republican voting patterns.
State Representative Sam Pirozzolo kicked off the latest secession movement by hosting a rally where he read the “Staten Island Declaration of Independence.” This event took place at the site where the Declaration was first read on Staten Island back in 1776.
“I wanted to make use of Mr. Mamdani’s recent election as mayor,” Pirozzolo explained. “This isn’t a declaration of war on Manhattan, but it should have some implications.”
The borough has contemplated leaving New York City since at least the 1940s, coming close in 1993 when a non-binding referendum showed 65% support. However, hopes dwindled when the then-Council Speaker refused to endorse the necessary measures.
Any secession would require state approval. Lanza’s bill seeks to bypass the city’s approval process but still encourages Staten Islanders to vote on the matter.
Meanwhile, Councilman Frank Morano is drafting a bill that would require the city to assess the economic impacts of Staten Island becoming an independent city. Concerns linger over potential tax hikes if the borough loses essential services provided by New York City, including police and education.
Previous attempts at similar legislation by former Republican Council Minority Leader Joe Borrelli did not gain traction, but Morano aims for a balanced approach. He acknowledges the strong local sentiment for independence but expresses worries that full autonomy could elevate taxes for residents.
Morano suggests that a referendum should ultimately decide the future. “It’s incredibly frustrating for Staten Island residents when their votes are overlooked by officials from other parts of the city,” he remarked.
As the least populated borough with about 500,000 residents, Staten Island could become the second-largest city in New York State, exceeding the populations of cities like Miami and Cleveland.
Lanza also believes an upcoming gubernatorial election may bolster support for secession, especially if there are shifts in political leadership. So far, Mamdani and his representatives have not commented on the situation.
