Ordering steak can be less straightforward than it seems. Cuts, grades and cooking styles all affect what arrives at the table, and diners may not always get what they expected—or what they thought they ordered.
An Illinois customer recently drew attention online after saying Texas Roadhouse served him sirloin instead of filet mignon on three occasions. The restaurant confirmed one mistake and said its managers addressed it. The story also prompted many people to wonder whether they could tell the two cuts apart.
Butchers and chefs say the right steak depends largely on what you value most. Katie Flannery, a third-generation butcher at Flannery Beef in Northern California, calls filet, rib-eye and New York strip the “holy trinity” of steak cuts.
Filet mignon is prized for its tenderness. It comes from a little-used muscle, but tends to have a milder flavor than other popular cuts. It is often the priciest option, partly because each animal yields relatively little filet.
Rib-eye is a better fit for diners looking for a richer beef flavor, Flannery said, though it generally has more chew than filet.
John Tesar, executive chef of Palladino’s Steak & Seafood in New York City and Dallas, said rib-eye combines a tender center with a firmer, more flavorful outer section, with fat running through the cut.
New York strip is another hearty option. It is usually easy to recognize by the strip of fat along one edge. Flannery said it is less flavorful than rib-eye and may be chewier than filet, depending on its grade.
A porterhouse offers two cuts in one: New York strip and filet, separated by a bone. It is often large enough to share.
Menu wording can add to the confusion. A “sirloin filet,” for example, may be sirloin cut or shaped to resemble filet mignon. Sirloin comes from the hip and rump, which get more use than the muscle filet comes from, so it is typically less tender.
USDA grades provide another point of reference. They indicate the amount of marbling—small flecks of fat within the muscle—which can affect flavor and tenderness. The main grades are Prime, Choice and Select, with Prime at the top.
Filet, rib-eye, New York strip and sirloin may all come from beef graded Prime, Choice or Select. The USDA assigns a grade to the carcass, meaning cuts from the same carcass share that grade. Grading is voluntary, so some beef is not graded.
Flannery estimates that about 10% of graded cattle qualify as Prime and roughly 70% as Choice. Prime beef has more marbling than Choice or Select. That can add flavor and tenderness, though it is not the only thing that matters. Muscles used more during an animal’s life tend to be tougher, she said.
Both wet-aging and dry-aging can make beef more tender. Dry-aging also concentrates flavor. Wet-aging is common, Flannery noted, so seeing it mentioned on a menu may not be particularly unusual. In wet-aging, beef is vacuum-sealed and refrigerated; dry-aged meat is exposed to air in a cooler, which causes some moisture and weight loss.
The appearance of a steak can offer clues, too. Tesar said filet mignon is generally thick and round, while rib-eye has a distinctive outer portion known as the rib cap, or spinalis.
On raw meat, filet tends to have finer muscle fibers, while sirloin’s grain is more visible, Flannery said. But sirloin can be cut into a rounded shape sometimes called a “baseball” steak, which may look much like filet mignon.
Once a steak has been sliced or covered with sauce and toppings, identifying it can be harder. Luis Haro, vice president of culinary innovation at Logan’s Roadhouse, said a whole steak is usually easier to recognize by its shape.
If the menu description is vague, diners can ask their server what cut is being served and what to expect. If the steak looks different from what they ordered, Tesar suggested raising the issue politely and asking the server to explain how it is being presented. If that does not clear things up, diners can ask to speak with the chef or a manager.


