Stephen A. Smith supports the ‘black first’ identity harming black Americans

Stephen A. Smith Discusses Black Identity in Recent Conversation

In a recent discussion involving Brandon Tatum, Gary Chambers, and ESPN host Stephen A. Smith, Smith advocated for a concept he describes as a “Black First Identity.” This perspective seems to place black identity primarily within the context of historical oppression, rather than focusing on individual achievements.

“What’s the issue with identifying as black first, before anything else? Before being American, you’re black. And before that, you’re identified as something else. What’s wrong with that?” Smith posed to Tatum and Chambers.

Tatum responded by emphasizing diversity within the black community. He remarked, “Not all black people share the same experiences.” He elaborated that black individuals in different regions, such as New York and the South, have distinct cultural backgrounds. He also pointed out the differences between African immigrants and African Americans, noting, “We are as diverse as anyone else. So, when someone says, ‘I’m white first,’ what does that even mean?”

Smith countered Tatum’s argument by suggesting that it’s essential for black people to connect with their enslaved ancestors, insisting that “the remnants of that history persist in today’s society.” He likened identifying as black before American to a fundamental truth about one’s existence in America. “I know there’s a disadvantage. I’ve got to struggle and fight for my place,” he added.

He asserted that this viewpoint shouldn’t be regarded as pessimistic but rather as an acknowledgment of historical injustices inherent in the country.

Jason Whitlock, host of Blaze TV, expressed his discontent with Smith’s take. “Stephen A. Smith is damaging for American media. Here’s a guy making $20 million a year, talking about historical disadvantages—though he’s not exactly unqualified for his role,” he remarked.

Whitlock advised against reflecting on slavery or racism, especially when those experiences are not personally lived. “Did you ever run down a hill? Was it racism that caused you to repeat a grade?” he questioned, pointing out that Smith’s emphasis on a “Black First Identity” is more accurately a “victim-first identity.” He argued that it contradicts Smith’s claims of being a Christian and having a biblical worldview.