Peter Van Dyke said he kept believing that investigators would identify those responsible for his brother’s killing, despite a nine-month inquiry into what first appeared to be a fatal home invasion.
Kurt Van Dyke, a 66-year-old California surfing figure, was found dead in February at his apartment in Hone Creek, in Costa Rica’s Limón province. He had multiple stab wounds and signs of asphyxiation. His body was found beneath a bed, wrapped in a sheet.
His girlfriend, identified by local authorities as Arroyo, was arrested on Nov. 12. Peter said he remembered his brother as kind and generous, but had not known he was dating her. He remained in touch with Kurt’s former wife, and Kurt’s children often visited him.
Peter said his nephew had stayed in contact with local authorities during the investigation. Investigators told Kurt’s son they believed they had a strong case, but needed time to build it and follow the required judicial process before making arrests, Peter said.
Arroyo reportedly told police that armed intruders had entered the apartment, restrained her and stolen valuables. Authorities initially investigated the death as a home invasion.
Costa Rica’s Judicial Investigation Agency later arrested Arroyo, 31, and a 34-year-old man identified as Gutiérrez. Investigators allege Arroyo helped armed attackers enter the apartment on Feb. 14.
Authorities believe the pair planned to rob Van Dyke and take bank card codes connected to the hotel he owned in Costa Rica. During searches on Nov. 12, police seized a cellphone, a vehicle allegedly used in the crime and other items they consider relevant to the investigation.
Investigators also believe a gang staged the theft of Arroyo’s car to make the attack look like a robbery. They say this supports their theory that she helped plan it.
Arroyo and Gutiérrez were referred to Costa Rica’s Public Ministry, which will determine whether to bring charges.






