The Seattle Times moved quickly. The morning after independent journalist Nick Shirley withdrew his allegation that Lam’s Seafood Asian Market had committed EBT fraud, the paper published a story about the accusation. The International District business, which is owned by a local family, had said it was wrongly targeted, and Shirley’s claim had put its livelihood at risk.
That kind of follow-up is part of journalism’s job. But the question is whether the same standard applies when the Times itself makes a claim that others dispute.
In a Nov. 8 story about Washington voters’ strong support for Initiative 638, which would bar biological males from competing in girls’ K–12 sports, the paper included perspectives from both sides. Still, one paragraph stood out: it said there was no serious scientific evidence that transgender women or girls have an athletic advantage over cisgender women or girls, and that no transgender athlete had dominated at an elite college or professional level.
Since the story appeared, several writers have challenged that statement, citing research they say points to persistent athletic advantages.
Seattle radio host Jason Rantz, for example, referred to a 2020 study of U.S. Air Force personnel. It found that transgender women ran a 1.5-mile course 12% faster than biological women even after two years of hormone therapy.
Investigative journalist Benjamin Ryan highlighted a 2025 scientific paper that reported some advantages in strength, power, size and aerobic capacity may remain after testosterone suppression. He also pointed to a 2020 review suggesting transgender women lose about 5% of muscle mass after a year of hormone therapy.
Karen Crouse, formerly of The New York Times and now writing for Sport and State, cited a 2021 review that found strength, lean mass and muscle size remained above female levels after three years of hormone treatment. She also referenced a 2023 American College of Sports Medicine consensus statement on the performance advantages males typically develop during puberty.
That is a substantial body of research being raised in response to the Times’ assertion. So far, though, the paper has not issued a correction, clarification or editor’s note.
The criticism has been circulating on social media, and the paper appears to know about it. Ryan shared a screenshot of a reporter thanking him for his comments and saying they had been passed along to the newsroom. Crouse said she contacted several editors seeking clarification but got no reply. I also emailed the Times’ executive editor, managing editor and public relations representative on Monday. I haven’t heard back.
My email included links to the critiques and asked whether the Times might not consider the cited research “serious.”
If I were the publisher, I’d be concerned about whether readers still regard the paper as a serious source. Publishing a claim that critics say conflicts with peer-reviewed research, then leaving requests for clarification unanswered, looks like either pride or fear of addressing the issue. Maybe a little of both.
Journalists get things wrong. I certainly have. But mistakes call for accountability, not silence.






