The NFC South is football’s annual everyone-gets-a-trophy award

The NFC South is football’s annual everyone-gets-a-trophy award

The idea that the NFC South would be stronger in 2026 hasn’t aged well. At the end of last season, there were reasons to feel optimistic. Atlanta seemed ready to improve with Kevin Stefanski and Bijan Robinson. Carolina looked as though Bryce Young and Tetairoa McMillan might be building something. New Orleans had made a big splash in free agency, setting up hopes for a Tyler Shough breakout, while Tampa Bay still had a strong defense and an offense that seemed capable of holding its own.

Now the division is back to being a punchline. It’s the only division in the NFL without a team above .500, and it could once again send a host team to the playoffs while a clearly better team has to travel. That’s not going to quiet anyone’s complaints about the playoff format.

Still, somebody has to win the division. Here’s how the teams look right now.

Atlanta Falcons

Current record: 3-7
Remaining strength of schedule (lower is easier): -0.2
Upcoming opponents: Vikings, Lions, Browns, Commanders, Buccaneers, Saints, Panthers
Projected finish: 5-12

Trading Jessie Bates felt like Atlanta waving the white flag on the season. Probably the right call. The Falcons aren’t in a position to compete right now, and they still have some serious questions to answer at quarterback.

Bijan Robinson is the clearest bright spot on offense. Drake London is an excellent receiver, too, but it’s hard to show that when the quarterback play is this poor. He should finish with more than 1,000 receiving yards, because he’s talented enough to get there, but he has just one touchdown so far. Atlanta has struggled to throw the ball in the red zone. Some of that comes down to the team’s focus on running, though you’d still expect a receiver like London to produce more.

The defense hasn’t made the leap many expected. Atlanta is 23rd in points allowed, 25th against the pass and 19th against the run. There isn’t much this team does especially well, and without a reliable passing game, it’s difficult to create the big plays needed to climb back into games.

The rebuild goes on.

Carolina Panthers

Current record: 4-5
Remaining strength of schedule (lower is easier): -2.4
Upcoming opponents: Ravens, Buccaneers, Vikings, Saints, Bengals, Steelers, Seahawks, Falcons
Projected finish: 8-9

This has been a major season for Bryce Young. In his fourth year, he’s started to put things together and has shown stretches of top-10 quarterback play. The problem is that Carolina hasn’t found much consistency, with injuries at key positions making things harder.

The offensive line has been hit especially hard. Rookie Monroe Freeling was pushed into a starting role before he was ready, and left tackle has been a revolving door. Injuries at guard have also disrupted the offense and made it tough to build momentum. For now, Bryce Young, Chuba Hubbard and Tetairoa McMillan are having to drag this team toward wins.

The defense struggled for much of the season, leading Carolina to fire coordinator Ejiro Evero. It has improved since then, but the Panthers have been without their top three cornerbacks for several games. Pass rusher Nic Scourton was also injured in the preseason. It’s been one thing after another.

Carolina probably won’t reach its preseason expectations. Those early losses to Cleveland and Tampa Bay could loom large when the final standings are set.

New Orleans Saints

Current record: 3-6
Remaining strength of schedule (lower is easier): +3.3
Upcoming opponents: Bears, Bengals, Packers, Panthers, Cardinals, Falcons, Buccaneers
Projected finish: 4-13

The Saints are a mess. It’s not necessarily a lack of talent; something just seems off within the organization. They’re hard to define as a team, and not in a good way. The running game isn’t working, the passing attack is uneven, the playcalling lacks much spark, and the defense has been average. At times, New Orleans looks less like a team competing and more like one simply getting through the season.

It’s difficult not to wonder what’s happened inside the locker room. Tyler Shough has played well, but too many of his teammates seem unprepared on Sundays. The Saints are regularly caught off guard on both sides of the ball and often look short on answers once a game gets underway. They’ve shown what they can do in gritty wins over Lamar Jackson’s Ravens and the Giants, but those performances have been the exception.

It’s starting to feel as if Kellen Moore’s time in New Orleans could be running out.

Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Current record: 3-6
Remaining strength of schedule (lower is easier): -11.5
Upcoming opponents: Lions, Panthers, Chargers, Ravens, Saints, Falcons, Rams, Saints
Projected finish: 9-8

Tampa Bay’s defense has been remarkable, making it one of the NFL’s toughest teams to score against. The offense, on the other hand, has been a real problem.

Losing Mike Evans in free agency changed what this team could be, and Baker Mayfield has felt the impact. He’s averaging only a little over 150 passing yards per game and hasn’t been able to find much consistency with the players around him. Bucky Irving and Kenneth Gainwell have helped keep the offense going with a strong ground game.

The Buccaneers can beat just about anyone in an ugly, defense-first game. They haven’t done it often enough yet, but their remaining schedule is very manageable, which could help them put together a few wins. A key moment comes Monday night, when Tampa Bay hosts Carolina. I’d give the edge to the Buccaneers: they’ll take the division and reach the playoffs.

With Vita Vea anchoring the middle and a strong group of linebackers behind him, Tampa Bay could also give a better team trouble in the postseason by bringing pressure. If Mayfield can provide even a little more on offense, this is a team that could surprise people.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News