Complaints about officiating are common on NFL Sundays, but the Panthers–Saints game was frustrating for both teams. Travel problems forced the league to use a backup officiating crew, and the game was marked by questionable interpretations, missed calls and outright errors.
The most talked-about decision came late, when officials called pass interference on Saints cornerback Kool-Aid McKinstry. The penalty moved Carolina into field-goal range, and the Panthers won as time expired.
McKinstry and several of his teammates called the decision a bad one. Coach Kellen Moore also suggested it had gone against New Orleans. The call was debatable, though it came after a similar pass-interference penalty against Carolina on the previous drive.
Those two calls came at pivotal moments, but they weren’t the only problems. One particularly baffling decision was a 15-yard facemask penalty against Carolina, even though the defender appeared to tackle the ball carrier by the shoulder pads without touching his facemask.
The 15-yard penalty is generally for an intentional facemask grab. In this case, it looked as if the officials may have judged the tackle by the way the runner fell rather than by what actually happened.
Carolina was also penalized for a horse-collar tackle on Saints quarterback Tyler Shough. That penalty doesn’t apply to a quarterback being brought down in the pocket, and the play appeared to end with Shough still between the hash marks.
More broadly, the crew seemed to flag a steady stream of marginal plays, including several calls that drew criticism from Fox Sports rules analyst Mike Pereira. Players were left looking confused, and the game became difficult to watch.
Officials called 20 penalties, 17 of them against the Panthers, for a total of 152 yards. The game was a sharp reminder of how much a crew’s mistakes can shape a result. NFL officiating can be inconsistent even on an ordinary Sunday; this was an especially rough example.

