Ryan Murphy’s “All’s Fair” Receives Dismal Reviews

If you’re into older actresses delivering less-than-stellar performances, this new show might just be for you.

Ryan Murphy’s latest production, “All’s Fair,” debuted to a shocking 0% rating from leading critics on Rotten Tomatoes. It’s notable that The Guardian, which has only published 17 zero-star reviews in its long history, included this piece among its rare critiques. Critics may be getting pickier, or maybe the quality of media we consume is just declining. Probably the latter.

Interestingly, viewers seem to have a different take. About 64% of users on Rotten Tomatoes rated the series at least 3.5 stars. Set in Los Angeles, the story revolves around a high-powered divorce attorney managing an all-female law firm. Starring several big names like Kim Kardashian, Glenn Close, and Sarah Paulson, the show had high expectations.

Ryan Murphy’s ALL’S FAIR debuted at 0% on Rotten Tomatoes. One critic said: “This may be the worst TV drama of all time.” pic.twitter.com/lvrRWI0AB6

—DiscussingFilm (@DiscussingFilm) November 4, 2025

A review from Hollywood Reporter criticized Kardashian’s acting as being hard and emotionless, but also noted that this very lack of emotion could add a unique value to the performance.

“All’s Fair” appeared to have the right elements for success—a group of middle-aged women uniting against older white male figures, embodying themes of feminine strength and empowerment.

Murphy, known for creating hits like “Glee,” “Scream Queens,” and “American Horror Story,” seemed poised for another success. However, many of his hits came during a time when societal representations were shifting significantly, reflecting diverse voices that were previously marginalized. This inclusivity helped him gain some favor with critics over the years.

Take “Glee,” for example. It ran for six seasons and became more than just a show, releasing numerous albums and tackling issues ranging from teenage pregnancy to LGBTQ+ themes. The later seasons introduced characters like Unique Addams, who navigated complex identities, adding layers to teenage storytelling.

Nonetheless, even the boldest narratives seem to be hitting a wall with some viewers and critics alike.