Texas think tank urges Trump to offer asylum to Michel Houellebecq
French novelist Michel Houellebecq is facing a criminal investigation over comments about Muslim migration and the possibility of violent resistance in France. A Texas-based think tank is calling on President Donald Trump to offer him asylum.
How it began
Houellebecq has repeatedly drawn criticism from Muslim organizations and European liberals for his writing and remarks about Islam and immigration.
In an interview shortly before the September 11, 2001, attacks, while promoting his novel Plateforme, he described Islam in sharply derogatory terms. He was later charged with inciting racial hatred, but a court acquitted him.
More than two decades later, he is again under scrutiny for comments made during a 2022 discussion with philosopher Michel Onfray. Houellebecq referred to the “Great Replacement” idea associated with French writer Renaud Camus, which holds that European populations are being replaced by migrants, many of them Muslim.
Houellebecq said he did not consider this a theory, but a reality. He attributed demographic change in Europe in part to low birth rates, rather than describing it as the result of a coordinated plot.
He also invoked the Reconquista, the centuries-long campaign by Christian forces to retake the Iberian Peninsula from Muslim rulers. Houellebecq said some people were arming themselves and taking shooting lessons. He predicted that if areas came under Islamist control, violent resistance could follow, including attacks on mosques and cafes frequented by Muslims. He compared such attacks to the 2015 Bataclan and Paris attacks, but in reverse.
The November 2015 attacks, carried out by Islamist militants at the Bataclan concert hall and other sites in Paris, killed 130 people and injured 368.
In other parts of the conversation, Houellebecq criticized Muslim migrants and suggested that native-born French people wanted them to stop attacking them and leave the country.
What has happened since
The Union of Mosques of France filed a complaint in 2023 against Houellebecq, Onfray and the publication that hosted their discussion. The organization argued that the novelist’s remarks amounted to violence and violated the dignity of French Muslims.
Houellebecq later apologized to France’s Muslim community and appeared to try to have the discussion removed from circulation. That did not end the dispute.
A criminal investigation was opened last week, according to a report citing a person familiar with the case. Houellebecq is suspected of complicity in inciting discrimination, hatred or violence. If convicted, he could face a substantial fine and as much as a year in prison.
The Union of Mosques of France welcomed the legal action, saying it wanted such remarks to be punished severely and to end what it described as a sense of impunity.
Houellebecq’s lawyers said he regretted the increasing tendency to take intellectual debate to court. They added that predicting disaster does not mean wishing for it, and argued that the novelist’s place was not in a courtroom.
Free-speech advocates have also criticized the case. Sarah McLaughlin of the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression said people must be able to discuss consequential questions of politics and religion. She argued that Houellebecq’s comments, and criticism of them, should be addressed in public debate rather than in court.
Deniz Yucel, a spokesperson for the writers’ association PEN Berlin, said people could reasonably debate whether Houellebecq’s remarks were justified, exaggerated, provocative or offensive. But, Yucel argued, the comments were protected expression, and warning about violence was not the same as encouraging it.
The Brownstone Institute, a Texas think tank, has urged Trump to offer Houellebecq asylum. In an article published Monday, the institute said free speech and opposition to migration were important themes in Trump’s political resurgence.
The institute also argued that Houellebecq would not require the public assistance it associated with some refugees, and pointed to earlier cases in which the United States granted asylum to writers from South Africa and Mexico.
The proposal came days after retired U.S. diplomat Alberto Miguel Fernandez posted that it would be notable if the U.S. government offered Houellebecq political asylum, even if the novelist might decline.
The White House had not responded to a request for comment by publication time.



