Defense Seeks Pause in Further Ballistics Testing in Charlie Kirk Case
Tyler Robinson’s attorneys are asking a Utah judge to temporarily halt additional testing of bullet fragments recovered during Charlie Kirk’s autopsy. Prosecutors want the FBI to examine the fragments in an effort to determine whether they came from the rifle Robinson is accused of using. The connection has not been conclusively established, and some experts say further testing may not be necessary.
The Utah County Attorney’s Office opposes the request. Prosecutors say the proposed analysis will not consume the evidence and that the defense can examine it after the government’s testing is complete. They also argue that other evidence will play a stronger role at trial.
In court filings, Deputy County Attorney Ryan McBride said there was no reason to think the fragments would contain evidence favorable to Robinson. He argued that the available information instead points toward the fragments being incriminating.
Prosecutors say Robinson allegedly admitted to the shooting, and that three unfired cartridges found in the rifle were consistent with the shot fired at Kirk. The recovered fragments are also consistent with the suspected weapon, though investigators have not conclusively matched them to it. Prosecutors have additionally cited video and a Dremel tool they say are consistent with markings found on brass casings recovered at the scene.
The proposed procedure, called virtual comparison microscopy, is expected to alter the fragments physically, even if it does not destroy them. According to court filings, examiners may need to fold back warped metal edges, clean small areas or scrape lead to reveal markings. There is also a chance that pieces could break off.
Robinson’s lawyers want the testing delayed until they can inspect and photograph the fragments. Alternatively, they have asked to have a defense expert observe the process in person or by video. The FBI does not permit that kind of observation in some cases, citing concerns such as contamination and national security. The defense says earlier ATF testing already affected the evidence and further examination could cause additional damage.
Retired FBI supervisory agent Jason Pack said the ATF could neither conclusively match the fragment to the rifle nor rule the rifle out. That distinction, he said, helps explain why prosecutors are seeking another examination. Virtual comparison microscopy uses more advanced methods than a conventional microscope, but it still may not produce a definitive match. If identifying marks are too damaged or no longer visible, Pack noted, technology cannot restore them.
Kirk was shot at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10, 2025, during a Turning Point USA speaking event, according to the case filings. Investigators recovered a bullet-jacket fragment and four pieces of lead from his body during the autopsy.
Robinson’s attorneys argue that if further testing makes an independent comparison impossible, the harm to the defense would be substantial. They say they could be unable to verify the findings independently, challenge expert conclusions effectively or ensure the jury hears evidence that can be properly contested.
Former ATF special agent Bernard Zapor said the concerns may be overstated. He said the agency documented the fragments in detail during its initial examination, and that photographs and other records are available to the defense. Since the first analysis was inconclusive, he added, damage from another round of testing might not substantially change the evidence. In his view, the dispute risks distracting from the jury’s task of weighing the full case.
During the earlier examination, ATF examiner Samantha Karner cleaned and photographed the jacket fragment, then folded back its edges to inspect groove marks. She determined it was from a .30-caliber class firearm but could not conclusively link it to the suspected weapon, a .30-06 Mauser rifle belonging to Robinson’s grandfather. Prosecutors say Karner had limited detail to work with and later identified 3D imaging as a possible way to obtain a clearer comparison.
Prosecutors say the FBI’s scanning process creates multiple three-dimensional images and preserves the scan data for the defense to review. They are also seeking metallurgical testing of the jacket fragment and at least one lead fragment. That work may involve cleaning a small area before examining it with an X-ray. Pack said a separate comparison of the fragments’ metal with ammunition seized during the investigation could provide more information, though it would not identify the firearm conclusively.
Prosecutors also want an examiner to take apart one of the unfired .30-06 cartridges recovered from Robinson’s home after his arrest. Robinson has pleaded not guilty to all charges. If convicted of aggravated murder, he could face the death penalty.

