Schaefer’s Stellar Performance Surprises Many
Matthew Schaefer aimed to just get through training camp with the Islanders, and, honestly, it seems like he really meant that.
When Adam Pelech hit the ice with Schaefer during the summer, he had no doubt about Schaefer’s place on the team. Not a hint of uncertainty.
“I mean, he’s obviously special — being the No. 1 overall pick — but I found him incredibly impressive,” Pelech shared. “People kept asking, ‘Do you think he’ll make the team?’ And I was like, ‘Of course. He’s going to be one of our best players.’ You could see it instantly.”
And honestly? Pelech might have even underestimated Schaefer’s abilities.
After just 27 games into the season, not only was Schaefer one of the Islanders’ standout players, but he was also being recognized as one of the best defensemen across the league.
He’s already broken records, become synonymous with the Islanders, entered discussions for a spot on Team Canada, and is currently leading the Calder Trophy race.
Initially, the Islanders planned to ease Schaefer into his role, perhaps positioning him on the third defensive pair or giving him minutes on the second power play unit.
But then things changed dramatically in just the second game of the year. Schaefer logged over 26 minutes and took control of the matchup against the Capitals.
Fast forward a month later, and he’s not only on the top defensive pair but also handling the top power play unit. I mean, what else could the team do? It would have been unrealistic to hold him back.
Now, he’s also taking on the challenge of matching up against the opposing teams’ top lines, and frankly, he seems to be more than comfortable with the situation.
“Honestly, I believe his skating alone sets him apart,” Matt Barzal commented last week. “Sure, plenty of players can pull off moves, but look at someone like Connor Bedard — he seemed held back by his speed initially. But watching Schaefer, it feels like he’s one of the fastest on the ice right now. Speed might take time to develop for some, but he’s got it already. It’s already making him a game-changer.”
Barzal, who had one of the most impressive rookie seasons for the Islanders in 2017-18, had 85 points but started at age 20. Schaefer, on the other hand, just turned 18 this past September.
“You can see the excitement in him, like those big-eyed moments when he steps on the ice,” Barzal shared. “He wants to showcase his talent to the fans and get them on their feet. I felt that way during my rookie year; he has that same fiery desire.”
If Schaefer’s goal is to make a name for himself, he’s already nailed it. In what feels like no time, he’s become one of the most recognized names in the NHL. Yet, he doesn’t come off as someone overwhelmed by it all.
“If you put in the hard work, things will align,” Schaefer told the Post. “You just need to stay grounded and dedicated. Sure, without effort, results might not come. I’ve been putting in the work since I was a kid, and it’s definitely paying off now.”
Patrick Roy, who’s coached in the Quebec Major Junior League, often encourages young talent to be themselves, embrace risks, and feel trusted, even when mistakes happen. Even those highly-touted prospects are expected to face challenges early on.
Interestingly, Roy sees comparisons between Schaefer and Nathan MacKinnon, whom he coached early on at Colorado State, noting that Schaefer hasn’t encountered many of those difficult moments. Given Schaefer’s limited play last season due to a collarbone injury, it only makes his current success more impressive.
“I believe it’s essential to comprehend these experiences and maintain the drive I’ve always had,” Schaefer said. “I aim to improve every single day, both on and off the ice.”
