Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney has pushed back against President Donald Trump’s assertion that Canada owes its existence to the United States. Speaking at a cabinet retreat in the Plains of Abraham, Quebec, Carney emphasized the importance of the relationship between the two countries, describing it as “remarkable” in terms of economy, security, and culture. However, he firmly stated, “Canada does not ‘live because of the United States.’ Canada thrives because we are Canadians,” asserting that the future of Canada is in its own hands.
In response to a request from Fox News Digital, the White House referred to Trump’s post on Truth Social. In that letter, Trump informed Carney that Canada’s invitation to join the U.S.-led Peace Commission, aimed at managing Gaza’s future after conflict, had been revoked. He expressed, “the Peace Council may withdraw at any time Canada’s invitation to join the most prestigious leadership council ever assembled.”
The tensions between Carney and Trump escalated during their respective speeches at the World Economic Forum in Davos. While Carney did not mention Trump directly, he criticized the current state of the international order, stating it was “disappearing” and that middle powers like Canada need to embrace the opportunity to create a new order reflecting their values.
Conversely, Trump openly attacked Carney, suggesting Canada should be thankful for the numerous benefits it receives from the U.S. He noted, “Canada lives because of the United States” and added a pointed reminder for Carney to keep that in mind.
The growing rift between Trump and Carney becomes more evident as both leaders articulate contrasting views on Canada’s role and their relationship. Carney, during his address, voiced the need for Canada to assert itself and build a future grounded in its own principles.
