Notre Dame’s Director Appointment Withdrawn Amid Controversy
Last month, the University of Notre Dame in Indiana declared that Susan Osterman Liu had been chosen as the new director of the Asia-Pacific Research Institute. However, her hiring was met with criticism due to her pro-abortion stance, which many felt clashed with the Catholic values upheld by the institution.
This situation sparked discomfort among members and supporters of Notre Dame, including clergy, prompting significant backlash. Many voiced concerns that the appointment contradicted the teachings of the Catholic Church, igniting protests from scholars, alumni, and advocates alike. Notably, 15 bishops and two archbishops expressed their disapproval, calling for a retraction of Osterman’s appointment.
Mary Gallagher, Dean of the Keogh School of International Studies, noted in a letter that Osterman ultimately decided against taking the position. In her correspondence with students and faculty, Osterman mentioned her belief that focusing on her appointment might distract from the important work of the Institute. She emphasized that creating a space where diverse voices can thrive is essential, hinting at deeper communal issues.
Bishop Kevin Rose of the Catholic Diocese of Fort Wayne-South Bend previously condemned Osterman’s views, describing them as disqualifying. After Osterman’s decision not to accept the role, Bishop Rose conveyed his gratitude to those in the Notre Dame community who opposed the appointment, emphasizing the importance of upholding the university’s Catholic mission.
Mary Fiorito, a senior fellow at the Catholic Association, remarked that Osterman’s withdrawal represents a victory for clarity and consistency. She reiterated that as a Catholic institution, Notre Dame has a commitment to uphold its values, which Osterman’s public advocacy for legal abortion could have undermined.
The tension culminated in actions from various student groups, like the Notre Dame Right to Life, who organized protests urging the administration to reconsider the appointment. Following Osterman’s choice to step down, students planned a prayer procession to show gratitude for the decision and reflect on the university’s Catholic identity.
