Mayor Zoran Mamdani’s appointment of a corruption watchdog has drawn significant criticism from local lawmakers due to his prior donations and support to his campaign during a contentious meeting on Monday.
Nadia Shihata, a former federal prosecutor nominated by Mr. Hizner to lead the investigation, faced tough questions regarding her connections to the mayor and her independence during her confirmation hearing.
Shihata stated that she had donated $700 to the Democratic Socialist Rebel Mayoral Campaign on four occasions last year, noting that this was her first contribution to a local or state candidate.
City Councilor Nantasha Williams (D-Queens) pressed Shihata about expectations for watchdog leaders, indicating that they usually do not contribute to the mayors who appoint them, which was a pertinent point considering Shihata’s involvement.
In addition to her financial donations, Shihata mentioned she had also spent “about an hour” canvassing for Mamdani, which she admitted could demonstrate a higher commitment compared to merely donating money.
Shihata defended her impartiality when pressed by Councilor Williams, who questioned whether she might favor the mayor. “Anyone who knows me,” she stated, “can vouch for my professionalism and integrity throughout my 20-year career.” She expressed a willingness to investigate any matter, even those involving the mayor.
The Department of Investigation (DOI) previously assisted in the indictment of former Mayor Eric Adams amidst various corruption-related inquiries, which adds to the tension surrounding Shihata’s current position.
Over the past decade, Shihata has reportedly donated close to $5,000 to various Democratic figures, including Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, as noted in federal election documentation.
Further questions emerged regarding her relationship with Ramzi Kasem, Mamdani’s chief and legal advisor, particularly since his position falls under the DOI’s jurisdiction.
Shihata testified that she had applied for the DOI role after Kasem reached out to her, although she claimed her interest had been considered prior to that contact when the departure of a previous commissioner was announced.
Shihata clarified that while she knew Kasem since 2003, their interactions were infrequent, consisting of occasional meetings and emails.
She also indicated she wouldn’t withdraw from any investigation related to Kasem unless advised by DOI’s internal counsel.
City Hall spokesperson Dora Pekek voiced support for Mamdani’s choice, highlighting Shihata’s reliability, extensive federal experience, and her longstanding commitment to fighting corruption.
Interestingly, the case of former DOI Commissioner Mark Peters is noted as a rare instance where a supervisory general made a donation to the mayor’s administration, which highlights the controversial nature of such contributions.
