Teachers Unions Urge Governors to Reject Education Freedom Tax Credit
Recently, leaders from the largest teachers unions in the U.S. sent a letter to Democratic governors, urging them not to engage with the new federal Education Freedom Tax Credit. Their stance? This initiative poses a threat to public education and should be dismissed.
However, this viewpoint doesn’t quite hold water.
It overlooks the fact that the tax credit is designed to help students in various educational settings—not just those in private schools. This mischaracterization could mislead families about what is arguably one of the most significant opportunities to enhance educational support in years.
Opponents of educational choice often argue that giving families more options will draw resources away from public schools. We’ve heard similar arguments against charter schools, tax-credit scholarships, and education savings accounts. Now, the same concerns are being raised about the Education Freedom Tax Credit.
But the facts tell another story.
Beginning in 2027, those with a federal tax liability can earn a dollar-for-dollar federal tax credit of up to $1,700 when they donate to approved scholarship organizations. So, instead of sending money directly to the IRS, donors can use that money to expand educational opportunities for students in public, private, and homeschooling environments. It’s a way to promote charitable giving that aims to benefit students directly.
Contrary to what critics claim, the Education Freedom Tax Credit will not divert state education funds. It won’t lead to budget cuts for districts. Families won’t be forced out of public schools; rather, it will introduce a new avenue for privately-funded educational support through donations.
No district’s budget will be affected, and funding for local public schools will remain stable.
Charitable contributions could help eligible students afford private school tuition. Plus, students who attend public schools might access tutoring, specialized services, advanced coursework, and other resources that might be out of reach otherwise.
This initiative shouldn’t be perceived as a threat to public education but rather as a means to support students no matter where they learn.
Let’s face it—America’s education system is facing serious challenges. Despite years of increased funding, many students struggle with basic reading and math skills, often falling behind and graduating without the necessary knowledge to thrive.
Additionally, the mental health crisis among students is at an all-time high. Parents are witnessing these issues firsthand and are eager for alternatives. The Education Freedom Tax Credit could be part of the solution.
For the first time, the federal tax system will facilitate charitable giving on a broad scale, connecting students with personalized educational opportunities.
Across the nation, more families are engaging with educational choice programs. Polls reveal that 70% of parents support their state participating in this tax credit, while only 9% are against it. There’s a clear desire for more options and resources, and donors are likely to respond to these needs.
Teachers unions have made their priorities clear—they seem more invested in maintaining political influence than expanding educational prospects for families. For too long, powerful interests have treated families as if they existed merely to support schools. In truth, schools exist to serve students and their families.
Governors now have a clear choice: they can opt to participate in this initiative to enable their students to benefit from resources generated within their communities, or they can watch as those resources go to students in states that embrace the program.
It’s essential to hear the voices of families rather than the special interests seeking to maintain the status quo. Ensuring kids have access to the opportunities this initiative offers should be the priority.
The focus shouldn’t be on what protects the system; instead, it should be on what will help each child thrive.
