Without Waze last month, many Americans were unable to travel beyond their driveways. Without the Starbucks app, many people had face-to-face interaction with a barista for the first time in years. The lack of voice calling capabilities has led at least a few teens to pick up phones for the first time, which are connected to a wire connected to a wall outlet.
A major cell phone service outage on February 22 disrupted millions of AT&T, T-Mobile, and Verizon customers across the United States.whether caused by a nation-state actor such as China; bolt typhoonor human error, or natural events, the direct and radial effects of power outages served as a stark reminder of the dependence of most Americans on cell phone infrastructure.
In everyday life, living without a smartphone means that many daily activities are delayed, interrupted, or canceled. February 22nd was such a day. But there are some days when you can expect a power outage to have a special impact, such as traveling during the Thanksgiving holiday or keeping in touch with kids over Halloween. A power outage on such a day could cause significant delays and anxiety for parents, but the impact could be personal and limited.
However, there are days when loss of connectivity can have devastating effects on democracy and national security. If such a power outage were to occur in the United States on Election Day this November, millions of people could be disenfranchised and the political, social, and strategic implications could be long-lasting and destabilizing. .
While it is difficult to predict the full impact of large-scale cell phone service outages on U.S. elections, it is an issue that government officials and voters must address immediately. When it comes to local belongings and personal effects, many voters may not be able to find their polling place, arranging transportation for elderly or infirm voters may be more difficult, and election officials, law enforcement officers, etc. Communication and coordination between enforcement agencies and other government officials may not be in time. It may cause problems or report results as expected.
In terms of domestic and international implications, a mobile phone network outage on election day could have far greater consequences. In addition to the challenges of a close or close presidential election, much is in the balance in a congressional race. A cellphone network outage that affects only left- or right-wing constituencies in a few metropolitan areas could be enough to change majorities in both houses of Congress. This would have major implications for social programs, military spending, and immigration policy, driving a wedge into an already fragile and partisan system.
Potential consequences of election day power outages include political parties fabricating events or colluding with their opponents to blame their opponents, especially if power outages occur in geographic areas that favor one party. is expected. The defeated candidate will likely argue, with or without good reason, that: They are We would have won if there had been no power outage. While such accusations may have become commonplace in recent elections, the Election Day outage could make the accusations more plausible, if not more accurate.
Far beyond Election Day, everyone from U.S. voters to world leaders openly questioned the legitimacy of democratically elected U.S. officials and criticized public institutions and U.S. international Americans’ confidence in their ability to exercise power may decline. A service outage on Election Day could irreversibly change the national security posture, severely impact the political system at all levels, and undermine the foundations of American democracy.
The critical issue highlighted by this failure was not only the realization that life would be more difficult without smartphone capabilities, but also, more importantly, that there was no Plan B. We are addicted to our devices.
Before the information age, civil society could operate safely and efficiently without constant connectivity. Nowadays, even people old enough to have lived without a smartphone cannot be expected to remember how to manage their daily activities in the absence of a smartphone. How many Americans had a paper map in hand instead of a navigation app on the morning of February 22nd? How many of us had a landline at home? The Starbucks app wasn’t working? How many of us had a coffee maker in our kitchen when we first realized it?
While individuals may not need to have a formal Plan B for their morning coffee, the country and its constituents need to have a strategy in place to deal with a similar event on November 5, 2024. There is. Polling stations are independent of smartphones, and authorities must know how to maintain communication and continue functioning. Early voting and voting by mail can reduce the impact of Election Day events, as can adjusting transportation in advance.
Election coordinators, from poll watchers to secretaries of state, can use approved alternative communications for official communications, such as providing information to the public about voting locations and times, requesting law enforcement assistance, and reporting election results. It is necessary to develop means. These mitigation measures are a start, but much more thought and effort is needed.
As of this writing, the cause of the failure is unknown. Whether caused by nation-states, human error, or other causes, this outage comes at a time when it would be most damaging to the United States and threatens to do the same to America’s adversaries. This should be treated as a warning that there is a possibility that Almost every presidential election since 2000 has been a new test for democracy. With the latest news reminders of the devastating effects of power outages, Americans should prepare now for disruption this Election Day.
Michael McLaughlin co-leads the Cybersecurity and Data Privacy Practice Group at Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, PC. He previously served as senior counterintelligence advisor for the U.S. Cyber Command and director of counterintelligence and human intelligence for the Cyber National Task Force. Kurt Sanger is the founder and director of Integrated Cybersecurity Partners, LLC. He served as a judge defense attorney in the United States Marine Corps for his 23 years. His last active duty post was as Deputy General Counsel for the U.S. Cyber Command.
Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
