A Tennessee judge has ruled that documents relating to the Covenant School killer cannot be made public “at this time.”
A legal battle is ongoing over the release of documents left behind by the killer. After last year’s tragedy, the Nashville Police Department vowed to release the documents, but that day never came. The FBI opposes releasing them, and the victims’ families oppose them being in the hands of the public.
“Because we can’t comply with both TPRA and federal copyright law, state law must compromise federal law.”
But the other side argues there is a compelling public interest and constitutional interest that requires the documents to be made public.
According to court documents, at 11:58 p.m., minutes before midnight on July 4, Davidson County Mayor Iasia Miles (Democrat) entered a ruling blocking the release of the documents, at least for now.
“Tennessee courts have determined that unfettered access to all records at any time does not serve to preserve the justice system that we all rely on to ensure that our criminal justice system and investigations remain fair and equitable for all involved,” Miles said. Her ruling reads:.
Judge Miles cited the Supremacy Clause of the Constitution as the legal basis for his decision.
“Federal copyright law, based on the supremacy clause and disputes preemption, serves as a valid exception to Tennessee’s public records law, preempting disclosure of any form of copyrighted work created by the aggressor,” she explained.
“Since we cannot comply with both TPRA and federal copyright law, state law must compromise federal law,” she added.
Legally, the victim has ownership of the documents after the murderer’s family receives them. Transferred legal ownership of them last year.
Judge Miles ruled that even documents not protected by copyright law do not have to be made public until “the investigation and any accompanying criminal proceedings are completed.”
In a statement after the ruling, the City of Nashville Said Authorities plan to release all documents, excluding those of the killer, once the investigation is complete, the statement added, adding that the investigation is “in the final stages.”
Victim’s family He praised the ruling.It will probably be appealed.
Do you like Blaze News? Bypass censorship and subscribe to our newsletter to get stories like this delivered directly to your inbox. Sign up here!
