Fox's first appearance – A Delaware court on Friday ordered Warner Bros. Discovery, the parent company of CNN, to turn over detailed financial documents if a subpoena is filed in support of the plaintiffs' high-stakes defamation lawsuit. If not, the company must submit a “sworn declaration'' that it will not do so. exist.
U.S. Navy veteran Zachary Young has accused his security consulting firm of making illegal profits by helping people escape from Afghanistan during the Biden administration's 2021 military withdrawal from Afghanistan. CNN claims he defamed the company Nemex Enterprises. Young believes CNN “ruined his reputation and business” during a segment on “The Lead with Jake Tapper.”
A Florida judge had previously agreed with Mr. Young's lawyers that confidential financial information presented by the cable network must be turned over to parent company Warner Bros. Discovery to determine CNN's net worth. But Young's lawyers said they had not received the proper documentation and had not filed an enforcement complaint in Delaware, home of Warner Bros. Discovery.
CNN faces defamation lawsuit over Afghanistan withdrawal story: 'evidence of actual malice'
A photo of plaintiff Zachary Young was aired by CNN during the segment in question. (CNN/Screenshot)
Young's attorneys, Blake Bennett and Joe Delich, said Warner Bros. Discovery has “failed to complete financial discovery” related to its cash flow statement and balance sheet.
“It is simply inconceivable that Warner Bros. Discovery would not be able to provide cash flow and balance sheet information for a wholly owned subsidiary,” Delich told Judge Lynn Parker.
“Warner Bros. Discovery has produced some documents, but no cash flow or balance sheet information,” he continued. “We know Warner Bros. Discovery has the ability to make this happen.”
Delich then explained that Warner Bros. Discovery prepares consolidated financial statements that are publicly filed with the SEC.
“To create consolidated financial statements, you have to consolidate something,” Delich said.
Defamation lawsuit against CNN could expose company's financial secrets as court aims to expose net worth
CNN host Jake Tapper and correspondent Alex Marquardt in the segment at the center of the defamation lawsuit. (CNN/Screenshot)
Jennifer Yin is the representative of Warner Bros. Discovery argued that the plaintiffs' team filed “premature motions” before the subpoena's return date and that the subpoena did not specify a cash flow statement or balance sheet. Yin also spoke to Warner Bros. Discovery has “repeatedly” stated that the document does not exist.
“We are not forced to produce something if it doesn't exist,” Yin said.
“We told them twice that no such information existed,” she continued. “They refused to accept that. You can't just create information that doesn't exist.”
Florida Judge William Henry, who is presiding over the case, previously ordered that CNN has a duty to “turn over everything in its possession, custody, or control,” but the law does not state that CNN executives He said there is no provision requiring the filing of an oath. A statement or declaration asserting that a document does not exist.
Judge Lynn Parker disagreed, requiring Mr. Young's lawyers to file a new subpoena specifying cash flow statements and balance sheets, and if the information was not turned over quickly, CNN's parent company He said he would be held accountable.
A woman in an Afghan burqa searches for recyclable materials among plastic waste at a garbage dump on the outskirts of Mazar-i-Sharif on September 28, 2024. (Photo by Atif Aryan/AFP) (Photo by Atif Aryan/AFP) ATIF ARYAN/AFP via Getty Images) (Photo by ATIF ARYAN/AFP via Getty Images)
“Well, CNN doesn't have to file an affidavit, but Warner Bros. does have to file an affidavit. Subpoena Warner Bros. to request these two specific things. So they're going to submit documents or they're going to submit to you 'a sworn declaration that that doesn't exist,''' Judge Parker said.
“Issue the subpoena immediately,” she continued. “Responses must be made within 20 days from the date of issue.”
The civil trial is scheduled to begin on January 6th in Bay County, Florida Circuit Court before Judge Henry.
The CNN section at the center of the lawsuit, which was shared on social media and repackaged for CNN's website, includes Tapper reporting that CNN correspondent Alex Marquardt says, “Afghans trying to leave the country… It began by telling viewers what they had discovered: “We are facing a black market full of promises.” , they charge exorbitant fees and there are no guarantees of safety or success. ”
CNN accused of withholding important documents needed to determine value ahead of defamation trial
CNN host Jake Tapper. (CNN)
Mr. Tapper addressed Mr. Marquardt, who said “desperate Afghans are being exploited” and must pay “exorbitant and often impossible amounts” to flee the country. Mr. Marquardt then named Mr. Young by name, flashed his photo on the screen, and offered $75,000 to transport the passenger-filled vehicle to Pakistan and $10,000 per person to arrive in the United Arab Emirates. He said the company is asking for $4,500.
“The price is out of reach for most Afghans,” Marquardt told viewers.
No other person or company was mentioned by name, but CNN inaccurately portrayed Young as a villain who preys on desperate people, using the words “black market,” “exploitative” and “outrageous.” He claimed to have painted it.
Internal communications between CNN employees revealed during discovery show that editors were concerned about the segment but aired it anyway. Other internal communications revealed that CNN employees used profanity and derogatory language when privately discussing Young.
Editor's Note: This article's headline states that if subpoenas are issued by plaintiffs, Warner Bros. Discovery will be forced to provide relevant financial information or otherwise prove they do not exist. Updated to clarify that.
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
