Republican presidential candidate President Donald Trump arrives to speak at a campaign event at the Cherokee Center in Harra on August 14, 2024 in Asheville, North Carolina.
Grant Baldwin | Getty Images
On the campaign trail, President Donald Trump touted plans to eliminate income taxes on social security benefits.
Now in the White House, Trump administration officials told CNBC.com last week that the president would “double” that promise.
Bills to eliminate these taxes – Elderly Tax Elimination Method – It was recently reintroduced at home.
However, taxes on Social Security benefits could reduce US government revenue by $1.5 trillion over a decade and increase federal debt by 7% by 2054. New analysis Penn Wharton's budget model, a nonpartisan research-based initiative at the University of Pennsylvania.
For some high-income households, policy changes could potentially earn up to $100,000 in profits over the course of their lives, the study found. However, individuals under the age of 30, especially those who have not yet been born, can face the biggest losses as federal debt increases and incentives to work and save for a decline in retirements increase.
Kent Smetters, professor of business economics and public policy at the University of Pennsylvania Wharton School, said there is a sense that the beneficiaries who paid the program for their entire work, their benefits should not be taxed. I stated.
How Social Security Benefits are Taxed
When Social Security Reform was passed by Congress in 1983, benefits were taxed for the first time. Then, in 1993, lawmakers added a second tax tier.
If you file taxes separately today, you will be able to get a beneficiary of what you call “total income” under $25,000, or $32,000 if you married and submitted jointly – Don't pay taxes The Penn Wharton budget model states about Social Security benefits.
The combined income is the total of half of adjusted gross income, non-tax interest and social security benefits.
Individual beneficiaries may pay taxes on benefits up to 50% for a total income of $25,000 to $34,000 or married couples between $32,000 and $44,000.
More details from personal finance:
“Take your hands off our social security,” lawmakers warn during Doge's budget cuts
Here is the change that Americans make to close the social security funding gap
Why retirees may find Social Security Coke alone in 2025 not enough
Up to 85% of benefits are subject to taxation if your total income exceeds $34,000. For married couples that apply when their total income exceeds $44,000.
These thresholds are not adjusted for inflation. That means more people Over time, you will be subject to Social Security benefits taxes.
How taxes on benefits are eliminated
Changes to Social Security will require bipartisan consensus from both the House and Senate.
Both House rooms have recently voted overwhelmingly to push forward the Social Security Equity Act. This is a new law that ends profit cuts for individuals who also receive pensions from jobs that do not include payment of Social Security payroll tax.
The change is estimated to cost almost $200 billion over a decade and move the Social Security Trust Fund bankruptcy to nearly six months. Congressional Budget Bureau. Prior to the change, Social Security Trustees predict that the program's total funding could be lost in 2035, at which point 83% of retirement, disability and other benefits will be paid.
According to Penn Wharton's budget model, elimination of Social Security benefits is more expensive – reducing revenue by $1.5 trillion over 10 years. If policy changes had been implemented in 2025, the Social Security Trust Fund would be nearly two years old, and analysis could be found.
William McBride, the Tax Foundation's chief economist, said Congressional lawmakers already deal with “a truly surprising budgetary situation,” so there are “some pretty strict restrictions on the tax cuts allowed.”
He said that it would cost around $4 trillion, especially if Republican efforts to extend the tax cuts and employment law were successful. The tax package, originally passed in 2017, excludes Social Security.
That leaves no room for tax exemption of Social Security income from many other “more expensive” ideas Trump mentioned in his campaign trajectory, McBride said.
Importantly, social security changes cannot be enacted through the settlement process. This may be used to quickly track other budget and tax measures.
Future generations will pick up bills
According to Penn Wharton's budget model, if taxes on Social Security benefits are eliminated, those at the top of household income distributions will see the biggest tax cuts. This ranges from $1,625 to $2,450 per year in 2026, increasing from $4,075 to $5,080 by 2054.
Low-income earners earn far less profits, with the second and third quartiles being Wharton's analysis has been found between $15 and $340 in 2026 and between $275 and $1,730 in 2054.
Analysis shows that all future generations will get worse, but the crisis will become more pronounced for those born in the future.
Certainly another proposal in Congress likewise calls for elimination of taxes on Social Security benefits, but also suggests that high-income earners pay additional taxes to the program to ease the increase in benefits. I'm requesting it.
But concerns about these changes will put financial pressure on the younger generation, while older people see higher benefits, Smetters said.
Economists often call this an implicit debt. There, intergenerational imbalances make future generations add at a higher cost.
“The people who pay for that benefit are actually young people,” Smetters said. “They're going to pay higher taxes now to pay it.”
