Three professors from Yale have decided to leave the United States for Canada, taking a stand against the Trump administration. Their departure suggests, perhaps, a disconnect regarding their purported concern over the country’s slide into fascism.
In a recent piece in the New York Times, Marci Shore, Timothy Snyder, and Jason Stanley—who all specialize in authoritarian studies—explain their reasoning for relocating. One professor, who has accepted a position at the University of Toronto, indicated that Trump might be transforming the government into an authoritarian state. “I want Americans to understand this is a democratic emergency,” Stanley declared.
Shore compared the situation to those onboard the Titanic, asserting, “There’s no such thing as a ship that can’t sink,” emphasizing the urgency of their warning.
Snyder mentioned that his reasons for leaving were a bit more nuanced, primarily revolving around supporting his family. He echoed concerns about the current state of freedom, claiming that teaching at a large public university would provide him opportunities to discuss these issues—something he could have done at Yale, just perhaps in a different context.
Interestingly, while many vocal critics of the current political climate threatened to flee but did not, the actions of these professors raise questions. Some might argue they are giving unwarranted credibility to those who flee. Take Rosie O’Donnell, for instance, who moved to Ireland but has publicly struggled with her mental health since the move.
But one has to wonder, by leaving, do these professors inadvertently show a lack of commitment to defending democracy? If they genuinely believe the country is teetering on the edge of fascism and have always been staunch advocates for democracy and human rights, why not stay and engage in the struggle? Why choose to relocate and miss the fight, heading north instead?
This behavior might suggest a detachment from a sincere concern for American democracy. While the metaphorical ship sinks, those who remain to battle through challenges may ultimately be the true stewards of democracy.
