Republicans Criticize Democrats for Blocking Anti-Semitism Bill

ALBANY – Republican lawmakers are frustrated after Democrats halted bills intended to strengthen the fight against anti-Semitism.

The legislation, introduced by Congressman Matt Slater (R-Putnam), aims to align New York’s definition of anti-Semitism with that of the International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance.

This revision would facilitate action against universities that tolerate hate speech under Title VI of the 1964 Federal Civil Rights Act.

“Defining hatred is the first step in combating it,” Slater remarked. “It seems Albany Democrats disagree.”

He continued, “It’s disappointing they won’t confront anti-Semitism when they have the chance, especially with the rise in hate crimes in our state since October 2023. They may condemn it when it’s convenient, but actions speak louder than words.”

The bill was discussed by the Congressional School Board on Tuesday, but Senator Michael Benedetto (D-Bronx), chairing the panel, expressed his disapproval, arguing that interpretations of the Civil Rights Act should be reserved for Washington.

Benedetto also raised concerns regarding the clarity of Slater’s proposal.

“The ACLU has issues with this, and I think it’s better to leave it to the federal government until these matters are resolved,” he stated.

This response sparked anger from Long Island Rep. Ali Brown (R-Nassau), who pushed back at Benedetto’s comments.

“Shouldn’t New York be a leader on this national issue?” Brown questioned. “We should be proud to take a stand, not waiting for the ACLU, which typically opposes what’s good for Jewish people.”

Benedetto mentioned that the original wording of the bill was meant to serve as “probably a guide post,” rather than a definitive standard.

During the discussion, he asked Brown to clarify which specific language was problematic. After a brief pause while staff engaged with the chairman, Brown replied, “I thought so.”

Ultimately, the school board voted to table the bill, essentially ending any chance for it to progress before Albany concludes its legislative sessions next month.

Slater’s proposal isn’t the only initiative seeking to incorporate the IHRA definition into state law. Congressman Sam Berger (D-Queens) is pushing similar legislation that extends to all state agencies, including SUNY.

Berger defended his fellow Democrats, stating, “I’ve seen speakers stand up for Jews repeatedly. There’s a disagreement among some Congress members on the best approach to combat anti-Semitism, but I feel a responsibility to address this alarming rise in hatred within our state.”