A judge appointed by Bush blocks Trump’s immigration rule and sharply criticizes the Department of Homeland Security for exceeding its authority

Trump approves executive order regarding strategy for foreign arms sales

Judge strikes down Trump-era rule restricting student and exchange visas

A federal judge has struck down an immigration rule developed by the Trump administration to address what it described as a gap in the visa system.

U.S. District Judge F. Dennis Saylor IV of Massachusetts ruled Monday that the Department of Homeland Security exceeded its authority when it imposed new limits on visas for international students, exchange visitors and foreign journalists. The decision is a win for labor unions and university leaders who challenged the rule, and another legal setback for the administration’s immigration crackdown.

The rule would have replaced a long-standing policy that allowed international students to remain in the country as long as they stayed enrolled and maintained legal status. Under the new system, students generally would have been limited to four years and required to seek an extension to continue studying. It also proposed tighter rules for changing schools or academic programs and pursuing further degrees, along with additional immigration reviews aimed at identifying fraud and security risks.

Saylor noted that students may have valid reasons to pursue another degree at the same or a lower level, such as earning an MBA after a law degree. The rule, he wrote, could effectively prevent them from coming to the United States for that purpose. He said the government’s stated concerns about national security and fraud were not reasonably connected to the purpose of the F-1 student visa program.

“Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity — providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States — that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” Saylor wrote. He added that federal law did not give the department such broad authority to undermine the program.

The judge had temporarily blocked the rule from taking effect in September. Monday’s decision went further, invalidating it after finding that DHS had violated federal administrative law.

Government lawyers argued that allowing students to remain for an indefinite period made it harder for immigration officials to check whether visa holders continued to meet the requirements. They said mandatory extensions would create more chances to detect fraud, security concerns and immigration violations, citing past cases of abuse in the student visa system.

Saylor said DHS had not adequately shown that its proposed approach would improve on existing safeguards. In particular, he questioned how a discretionary renewal process, applied after a student had already spent four years in the country, would meaningfully help uncover fraud or justify the costs of replacing the current system.

DHS currently uses the Student and Exchange Visitor Information System, known as SEVIS, to track international students and exchange visitors. The database records enrollment, immigration status and compliance with visa requirements using information provided by schools and program sponsors. The department has described SEVIS as a school reporting system, rather than a tool designed to conduct every type of fraud or security screening.

Saylor was described as a Republican in a 2014 profile and was reportedly considered for a role in the George W. Bush administration. The Senate confirmed him with bipartisan support, including from Democratic Sen. Ted Kennedy, who praised his fairness and independence.

DHS and the White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment on Tuesday.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News