A little-known IRS program may be unfairly hurting landowners

A little-known IRS program may be unfairly hurting landowners

A new analysis of Internal Revenue Service reviews is raising concerns about how the agency values conservation easements—and whether some landowners’ tax deductions were rejected before the details of their cases were properly considered.

Infinity Advisory Services examined more than 130 IRS valuation reviews. In 115 cases with comparable figures, the agency cut taxpayers’ appraised values by an average of about 97%; reductions of 99% or more were common.

The study argues that similar results across properties, tax years and reviewers suggest the agency may have been working toward a set outcome, rather than assessing each property independently. In the authors’ view, the reductions effectively erased the value supporting the deductions.

The tax incentive lets landowners claim a charitable deduction when they permanently give up certain development rights. The land remains theirs, but restrictions limit how it can be developed. Such agreements can protect farmland, forests and other land, and an appraisal of the donated rights generally determines the deduction’s value. That appraisal is often the point of dispute with the IRS.

The study’s authors say they set out to determine whether the government’s valuation position had been decided as policy before officials examined the facts of individual properties. The records they reviewed, they wrote, were consistent with that possibility and difficult to explain otherwise.

A former IRS valuator who worked at the agency for many years told Fox News Digital that he saw officials press appraisers toward predetermined conclusions and dismiss evidence from taxpayers who donated development rights. Rather than separating valid donations from abusive tax shelters, he said, the agency was putting some taxpayers it knew to be innocent at risk of large tax bills and penalties.

He said he believed the IRS had developed a culture in which collecting more money was treated as a positive outcome. In his view, officials were not always willing to consider facts from the taxpayer’s perspective, and the law was being applied unevenly. Valuation disputes, he added, should be handled by people with relevant expertise—something he said would not have been accepted when he worked at the agency.

One example in the study involves a historic building in Cleveland. The same IRS reviewer first valued a donated preservation easement at between $18.1 million and $23.2 million, then lowered the figure to $400,000 in a later review, substantially changing the landowner’s tax position.

The revised report referred to instructions from IRS counsel to leave certain development rights out of the calculation. The study’s authors say the change appeared to reflect a broader directive for a category of properties, rather than new evidence about the Cleveland building.

The former valuator also described a case he had dealt with in which the IRS listed eight concerns but, he said, declined to hear the taxpayer’s responses. When the taxpayer offered to address each issue, an IRS Appeals technical adviser reportedly replied that they did not want to hear it. The mediation ended without an agreement.

He questioned how officials involved in a dispute could refuse to hear a response to the issues they had raised. He said the matter should be examined on its facts and without partisan assumptions, rather than blamed on any one administration.

Steve Moore, chairman and co-founder of Unleash Prosperity and a former adviser to President Donald Trump, has also argued that the IRS’s scrutiny of conservation easement deductions has affected taxpayers who relied on qualified appraisers and professional advice.

Moore acknowledged that some easement cases involved fraud, including appraisals that substantially overstated a property’s value. But he said the crackdown had swept too broadly, treating honest taxpayers and fraudulent ones alike. After publishing an article on the issue, he said, he heard from families and landowners around the country who felt they had been treated unfairly.

In an August announcement, the IRS said standardized settlement offers with fixed deadlines did not work well for the wide range of conservation easement cases. The agency ended that initiative and announced the creation of an Office of Conservation Easements. The announcement did not directly address the study’s central concerns: whether the IRS gave fair consideration to evidence supporting deductions, and whether its valuations were independent or predetermined.

Moore said the IRS had recognized that its approach had angered people across the country, but he argued that little had changed for the taxpayers seeking relief. He warned that unresolved disputes could leave some people facing bankruptcy.

The IRS, asked for comment, referred Fox News Digital to its August announcement.

The agency has also won significant court cases involving conservation easement valuations, including two decisions in the past year.

In July, the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a $480,000 valuation for an easement covering 103 acres in Georgia. The partnership that claimed the deduction had put its value at $23 million. The court rejected the proposed quarry development used to support the higher figure, finding it economically unviable, and upheld a 40% penalty for substantially overstating the easement’s value.

In August, the same appeals court upheld a $900,000 valuation for a Georgia easement tied to an $8.9 million deduction claimed by Mill Road 36 Henry LLC. The court found that comparable sales and a recent transaction involving the land supported the lower figure. It also upheld a 40% penalty for overstating the value.

The Tax Court, meanwhile, has repeatedly rejected IRS attempts to impose civil fraud penalties in conservation easement cases. A February ruling cited three earlier decisions that reached the same conclusion, including Mill Road.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News