A scientist may never learn where the mysterious space object came from after the mission was canceled

Scientist challenges NASA chief over mysterious space object: “It’s not an asteroid”

Avi Loeb, a Harvard astrophysicist who believes a puzzling object in the solar system could be a missing Soviet spacecraft, says scientists may now have little chance of getting a detailed look at it. Japan has canceled a planned mission to visit the object in 2031.

Loeb said the decision by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency (JAXA) removes the best opportunity to photograph the surface of 1998 KY26 up close and determine whether it is a natural object or the lost Soviet probe Phobos 1, launched in 1988.

Even powerful telescopes, including the James Webb Space Telescope, cannot resolve the object into enough pixels to show its surface, Loeb said. A close flyby would be needed for high-resolution images.

The cancellation came shortly after NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said he had seen no evidence that KY26 was anything other than an asteroid. Loeb disagrees, arguing that its acceleration cannot be explained by gravity alone. He has speculated that a landing could reveal a Soviet label rather than rock or ice—a claim that remains unproven.

JAXA told Japan’s Space Policy Committee on Nov. 16 that it was dropping the rendezvous after Hayabusa2’s last normally functioning main ion engine malfunctioned in mid-August, according to the Yomiuri Shimbun.

Loeb said he was surprised by the timing, since the engine problem had reportedly been known for months. He estimated that the close timing between his public comments and JAXA’s announcement made a coincidence seem unlikely, while acknowledging that it could still be one.

He also questioned why the agency had not tried another Earth-gravity assist to make up for the lost thrust. JAXA officials said reaching KY26 already required such a maneuver. With parts from two damaged engines combined, the 12-year-old spacecraft would still lack the thrust needed for the required course changes, so the agency plans to redirect it toward a 2028 flyby of asteroid 2015 BM510.

Loeb said astronomers may still be able to learn more about KY26 remotely by using Webb to study its emitted heat and chemical spectrum. That could help estimate the object’s size, surface temperature and composition. So far, observations have detected reflected sunlight.

Loeb has also pointed to the object’s rapid rotation—about once every five minutes—and its unusual brightness. He said it reflects roughly half the sunlight that reaches it, compared with about 5% for a typical rock or iceberg.

NASA has cited a 2025 study by its Center for Near-Earth Object Studies, which found that KY26’s complicated path could be explained by forces from sunlight and heat radiating from the object’s irregular shape, rather than activity like that of a comet.

Loeb and his colleagues, however, say the object’s trajectory resembles that of Phobos 1, a Soviet spacecraft sent toward Mars in July 1988 that lost contact after a faulty command. They have proposed that sunlight reflecting off the probe’s solar panels could account for the observed acceleration.

A comet releasing gas could also be pushed along, Loeb said, but that explanation would normally be expected to produce visible gas or dust. He noted that sunlight pushes dust particles away from the Sun, creating a comet’s tail.

KY26’s orbit ranges from a fraction of the distance between Earth and the Sun to several times that distance. Loeb said it poses no impact threat to Earth, but argued that scientists should remain open to unusual explanations when studying objects they do not yet understand.

He pointed to an object briefly cataloged as an asteroid near Earth in January 2025 that was later identified as the Tesla Roadster SpaceX launched in 2018. Its identity was recognized because its flight path was known.

Loeb said he hopes the Rubin Observatory in Chile will discover many more interstellar objects over the next decade. Scientists, he argued, should investigate whether each is a natural body, since finding even one object of technological origin could change how people understand humanity’s place in the universe.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News