Debate Around Christian Nationalism and Immigration
Some pastors, like Ben Cramer, argue that prioritizing America’s interests contradicts biblical teachings, suggesting that enforcing border control is against Christian principles. They contend that intertwining Christian beliefs with public policy leads to what they label “Christian nationalism.”
However, Blaze TV host Allie Beth Stuckey counters these claims, stating that such assertions are misleading. She notes, “We often hear from people like Ben Cramer that it’s wrong to put your country first, or that it’s wrong to rely on conservative Christian views to help you vote.”
A few months back, Kramer addressed a common misconception, saying, “Myth #1: Immigrants are expendable to our country.” Stuckey expressed her interest not just in Kraymer’s statement but also in his subsequent reactions.
“The Bible doesn’t assign worth based on economic contributions,” she reads from Kramer’s response, referencing scriptures that highlight the importance of welcoming strangers without bias. “The call to welcome the stranger is tied to God’s nature, not their value to society,” she relayed.
Stuckey critiques this viewpoint, suggesting that Kramer conflates the U.S. with God’s Kingdom. “We’re discussing America here, not a theocracy,” she argues. By asserting that Christian nationalists wish to enforce a theocratic system, he is, in her view, muddling the lines between national governance and spiritual duties.
Stuckey further highlights that governments are established by God, referencing Romans 13:2-4, where rulers are described as God’s servants to ensure good governance.
She emphasizes the necessity of electing leaders who align moral definitions with biblical principles, reflecting on the divine origin of laws and governance.
In another post, Kremer mentioned that the essence of Christian nationalism is akin to declaring “America first!” when the biblical text promotes unity across nations, languages, and tribes. Stuckey pointed out the irony in such accusations, asserting that progressive beliefs often intertwine national identity with the church.
“Interestingly, the Bible does not seem to prioritize ethnic diversity within local or national churches,” she concluded, implying that this emphasis is largely absent from scriptural texts.
