Americans have made politics a substitute for religion, and it’s driving us crazy

Americans have made politics a substitute for religion, and it’s driving us crazy

Americans once seemed able to disagree about politics without seeing one another as enemies. Comedian, podcast host, and author Andrew Heaton says that has changed, and he joined Stu Burguiere and Dave Landau to discuss why in a conversation about his new book, Tribalism Is Dumb.

Heaton recalled that, growing up, he had relatives in Oklahoma who were Democrats, though their politics never stood out as a major part of who they were. Politics, he said, was more like routine administration than a defining identity.

That made it easier for people with different views to remain friends. They could share a community, perhaps attend the same local church, and disagree about an issue such as tariffs without letting it overwhelm the relationship. Heaton said he thinks that was a healthier way for the country to function, and it’s a model he hopes to understand through the book as he examines how Americans became so polarized.

Burguiere suggested the shift may have begun around a decade ago, but said the COVID pandemic seemed to intensify the country’s divisions. He also argued that the nation’s founders did not intend for government and politics to become the only things people focused on. Somehow, he said, the country has moved away from that idea.

Heaton described himself as a mild-mannered agnostic who has become increasingly supportive of religion, an unexpected position for him. He said that while people often talk about societies becoming less religious, he suspects the impulse toward belief and belonging has not disappeared. Instead, it may have moved from religion into politics—a replacement he considers especially damaging.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News