Self-defense claim weakens in road-rage killing as men face murder charges and former police officers face accusations

Self-defense claim weakens in road-rage killing as men face murder charges and former police officers face accusations

Two men charged in fatal South Carolina road-rage shooting

Two South Carolina men have been charged with murder in the 2023 shooting death of Scott Spivey. The case has also led to misconduct charges against two former county police officers, after evidence uncovered by Spivey’s sister challenged the claim that the shooting was self-defense.

Spivey, a 33-year-old insurance adjuster from North Carolina, died on Sept. 9, 2023. A car chase began on Highway 9 in Horry County and ended about nine miles away on Camp Swamp Road, where he was shot.

Charles “Weldon” Boyd and Kenneth “Bradley” Williams were arrested Wednesday, more than three years after the shooting. Both had initially said they acted in self-defense under South Carolina’s “stand your ground” law, claiming Spivey was driving erratically and posed a threat.

Former Horry County police officers Brandon Stickland and Paul Vescovi also face charges, including misconduct in office and obstruction of justice, according to local reports. Stickland, who allegedly spoke with Boyd by phone after the shooting, is additionally charged with criminal conspiracy.

All four appeared in court Thursday afternoon. The judge did not decide on their bond requests during a hearing that lasted about two hours. A decision is expected to be posted later.

Court documents say Spivey, Boyd and Williams were all armed. Spivey eventually pulled over, got out of his car and yelled at the other men to stop following him. His sister’s attorney later described the shooting as a “hail of gunfire” in a wrongful-death lawsuit.

Jennifer Spivey Foley, Spivey’s sister, found recordings from Boyd’s phone inside the police case file. The recordings had not previously been made public or considered in the case. Their release last year brought renewed attention to the investigation.

Foley attended Thursday’s hearing and asked the judge to deny bond for Boyd and Williams. She also requested a mental-health evaluation for Boyd.

According to documents in the family’s civil lawsuit, a recording captured Boyd telling a 911 dispatcher that Spivey was trying to get away, while also indicating he was prepared for a shootout. In the lawsuit, Boyd is alleged to have said he would shoot Spivey if he saw the gun again. He stayed on the call until the shooting, the complaint says.

Boyd later allegedly called a friend who was then Horry County’s deputy police chief, according to reporting on the case.

Defense filings in the civil case claim that Spivey pointed a pistol at Williams and forced Boyd’s truck off the road earlier in the encounter. In a 911 call, a man identified as Boyd told the dispatcher that the other driver had fired first.

Judge Eugene Griffith, who is overseeing the family’s wrongful-death lawsuit, ruled in that case that Boyd’s recorded calls showed he was seeking help from law enforcement while trying to avoid responsibility.

Boyd and Williams’ lawyers asked to pause the civil proceedings on Nov. 5, citing a pending grand jury inquiry. Court records show the men were indicted within days.

“For over three years, Scott Spivey’s family has fought for something that should never have required a fight — the truth about how and why Scott was killed,” Mark Tinsley, the family’s attorney, said in a statement. He added that the family had believed from the beginning that Spivey’s death was not justified.

A special prosecutor is handling the criminal case after local prosecutors declined to bring charges.

“The tragedy of this case is not just that Scott Spivey lost his life,” Tinsley said. “It is that his family had to fight the very system that was supposed to investigate his death to get to the truth.”

Spivey’s mother, Deborah Spivey, said last year that she did not accept the self-defense claim, noting that her son had allegedly been followed for nearly 10 miles before the fatal confrontation. She argued that the law did not apply if someone was trying to leave and calm the situation.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News