A California school district has approved a policy barring students it identifies as biologically male from girls’ sports, locker rooms and showers. The decision could lead to a legal clash with state officials, who had urged the district not to adopt the restrictions.
The Chino Valley Unified School District Board of Education approved the measure 4-1 on Thursday. It was authored by outgoing board President Sonja Shaw and faced opposition from the California attorney general’s office and the district teachers’ union.
Shaw, who has previously challenged state policies on parental rights and transgender students, described the vote as a major step toward protecting female athletes. She urged other districts to adopt similar rules.
“We passed actual board policy that establishes clear protections for girls in sports, locker rooms, showers, and overnight school travel,” Shaw said Friday. She said the rules would prevent boys from competing in girls’ sports or sharing girls’ locker rooms, showers and hotel rooms on school trips.
Shaw said Chino Valley Unified was the first California district to put such restrictions into formal policy, following a resolution she wrote in 2025 that other districts later adopted. She argued that families should not have to question whether their daughters’ privacy and safety are protected.
The policy, titled “Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities,” bases eligibility for girls’ teams on biological sex at birth rather than gender identity.
Under the related administrative rules, the district would generally use existing enrollment records showing a student’s sex at or near birth. If those records are unavailable or have been changed, the district may request a birth certificate issued around the time of birth or a statement from a licensed health care provider based on a routine sports physical. The rules prohibit additional exams, tests or inspections beyond the standard physical required of all athletes.
Shaw said the policy moves beyond expressing opposition to California’s existing rules for transgender students. She criticized adults and institutions for disputing responsibility, and said she believed more districts should follow Chino Valley Unified’s lead.
The vote came a day after the office of California Attorney General Rob Bonta sent the district a letter warning that the proposed restrictions conflicted with state law. Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent urged the board to reject the policy or delay its vote so the district could discuss how state law applied.
California’s 2013 Assembly Bill 1266, which allows transgender students to participate in school programs consistent with their gender identity, has become a point of conflict between state officials and the Trump administration over transgender participation in girls’ sports.
Shaw rejected the state’s warning, arguing that federal law should prevail if it conflicts with state requirements. The district policy cites U.S. Supreme Court decisions involving laws in West Virginia and Idaho that limit participation in female sports to biological females. Those rulings upheld the laws at issue, but did not establish a nationwide rule.
California continues to maintain laws allowing transgender students to compete according to their gender identity. In August, a federal district court dismissed the Trump administration’s lawsuit against the California Department of Education and the state’s interscholastic athletics organization. The court did not decide whether transgender participation in girls’ sports violates Title IX. It found that the federal government had not provided sufficient legal notice to make its interpretation a condition of federal funding.
Chino Valley Unified’s policy directs the superintendent to consult with legal counsel and take lawful steps to protect students and federal funding if state requirements are applied in a way that conflicts with the district’s new restrictions.
The vote took place at Shaw’s final school board meeting. She had recently run unsuccessfully for California superintendent of public instruction.
Shaw has also led efforts to require schools to notify parents about certain changes in students’ gender identification. That policy has prompted litigation involving Bonta’s office, amid a broader dispute over parental notification and state protections for transgender students.
In a statement, Shaw criticized the governor, attorney general, state lawmakers, teachers’ unions and the California Department of Education. She said she would continue advocating for sex-based eligibility rules in girls’ sports, despite leaving the board.
“This should be a wake-up call to every school board in California,” she said, adding that she would not back down from her commitment to protecting girls.






