Charlotte wants lawsuit over Iryna Zarutska’s murder dismissed, saying it can’t be held responsible.

Sheriff cautions that Iryna's Law will lead to overcrowded jails in Charlotte

Charlotte is asking a judge to dismiss a wrongful-death lawsuit brought by Iryna Zarutska’s family, arguing that decisions about public safety and transit security are protected by governmental immunity under North Carolina law.

Zarutska, a 23-year-old Ukrainian refugee, had just left her job at a pizzeria when she boarded a Lynx Blue Line train. Surveillance video showed Decarlos Brown Jr. sitting behind her before he allegedly stabbed her in the neck about four minutes later.

Her family sued the city and its transit security contractor, Professional Police Services, in August. The lawsuit alleges that failures to properly police and secure the rail system left passengers exposed to violent crime.

In a 34-page filing submitted Monday, Charlotte argues the family’s claims concern law-enforcement deployment, transit policing, crime prevention, contractor oversight and public-safety administration—all functions the city says are shielded from liability.

The filing acknowledges that no private security guard was inside Zarutska’s train car when she was killed. It also says Brown apparently boarded without showing a ticket or pass, noting that the system has no turnstiles or fare gates.

But the city disputes that those conditions caused Zarutska’s death. It argues Brown acted independently and that the attack could not have been anticipated based on earlier crime across the transit system. Charlotte also says that Brown’s failure to pay a fare did not indicate he would attack anyone.

The family’s lawsuit argues that better fare enforcement, physical barriers and adequate security could have stopped Brown from boarding or carrying out the attack. It also points to a state auditor’s findings that Charlotte and the Charlotte Area Transit System planned to spend about $2.23 million on safety and security equipment in 2025, but spent roughly $470,000. About $1.76 million remained unspent, and some planned security work was not completed.

Charlotte denies neglecting passenger safety. The city says the transit system had contracted armed and unarmed security, coordinated with law enforcement and pursued other safety measures before Zarutska’s death. It further argues that decisions about guard staffing and placement, surveillance and fare enforcement did not cause the killing. Brown, the city says, is solely responsible.

The family anticipated the city’s immunity defense, arguing that Charlotte waived immunity and that operating a fare-charging light-rail system is a proprietary, rather than governmental, function.

If the judge allows any claims against the city to proceed, Charlotte argues that damages payable to Zarutska’s estate should be capped at $1 million.

The city is asking the judge to dismiss all claims against it and bar the family from bringing them again. The judge has not yet ruled.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News