Christian nationalism for you, but not for me?

Christian nationalism for you, but not for me?

Senator-elect James Talarico says his support for abortion rights grows out of his Christian faith. He has read Mary’s response to the angel Gabriel as a lesson about reproductive choice, invoked Scripture in support of gay rights, and pointed to Jesus’ welcome of strangers when discussing immigration. At the same time, he often criticizes conservative opponents for promoting “Christian nationalism.”

That contrast invites a question: if using the Bible in political arguments amounts to Christian nationalism, what should we call progressive Christians who have done the same for generations?

Faith has a place in public life. The real issue is whether Scripture is allowed to challenge our political views, or whether we select passages to endorse positions we already hold.

The disagreement isn’t about whether religion belongs in politics, but about which understanding of Christianity should shape political choices. Talarico might say his objection is to using government power coercively, rather than to making biblical arguments. Fair enough—but that principle should also be applied to his own political agenda.

The danger is not always a direct rejection of the Bible. It can also come from appealing to biblical authority while setting aside passages that challenge a preferred cause, effectively reversing Scripture’s moral meaning.

An earlier debate at Princeton Theological Seminary offers one example. In the early 1900s, B. B. Warfield argued for rigorous theological education, while Charles R. Erdman stressed practical ministry and the social challenges facing communities. Erdman was not a theological liberal; he objected to forms of the Social Gospel that replaced Christian teaching with good works. Warfield worried that training ministers mainly for social service would leave them poorly equipped to teach and defend doctrine. Erdman, meanwhile, wanted pastors ready to address the everyday struggles of their congregations.

The disagreement pointed to a question the church still faces: is it defined primarily by the gospel it proclaims, or by the social programs it carries out?

Christianity cannot ignore poverty or oppression. Conservatives are mistaken when they act as if the gospel is only about the next life. But social action cannot take the place of salvation, either. Several movements show how that tension has played out.

Walter Rauschenbusch, one of the leading figures in the Social Gospel movement, understood the words “Thy kingdom come” as a call to build a fairer society. His concern for exploited workers and poor families was well-founded. But can Christ’s kingdom be equated with a human plan for social reconstruction? The gospel should change how people treat their neighbors, though it does not begin with an economic order designed by the state.

Harry Emerson Fosdick’s 1922 sermon, “Shall the Fundamentalists Win?,” drew on Gamaliel’s warning in Acts 5 not to oppose a movement that might be from God. Fosdick used the passage to defend theological liberals he believed conservatives were attacking unfairly. He also relied on Scripture to question traditional teachings about the virgin birth, biblical inspiration, and Christ’s return.

Latin American liberation theology, particularly the work of Gustavo Gutiérrez, treated the Exodus story as a model for release from political and economic oppression. Gutiérrez did not simply dismiss spiritual salvation, but political liberation became a central part of his account. The biblical story of deliverance was used to support social change; today, similar ideas are invoked in support of Marxist “decolonizing” movements.

These thinkers were not all alike, and their differences mattered. Still, their approaches raise three connected concerns.

First, they can blur the distinct responsibilities of church and state. In Romans 13:1-4, civil authorities are charged with maintaining justice and punishing wrongdoing. The church, according to Matthew 28:18-20, is called to proclaim Christ and make disciples. Government can require people to obey the law, but it cannot renew their hearts or make them love their neighbors.

Christians can support public policies for religious reasons without establishing a church. The First Amendment does not prevent people of faith from bringing their convictions into political debate, whether their views are progressive or conservative. But when government is treated as the means of carrying out the church’s mission of redemption, the distinction breaks down. A state has borders; Christ’s church does not.

Second, the gospel can be reduced too readily to material concerns. Some Christians minimize suffering in this life because they focus on heaven. Progressive theology can tilt in the other direction, suggesting that stronger institutions, redistribution, or expanded rights can bring about God’s kingdom on earth. Christ did not come simply to improve life under fallen conditions. He came to save people from sin and death. Feeding the hungry is important, but it cannot replace reconciliation with God.

Third, political change cannot give someone a new heart. Scripture speaks of renewal, forgiveness, and release from sin’s power, as in Ezekiel 36:26 and Romans 6:22. It also calls people to turn away from conduct that some progressive Christians now affirm, including same-sex sexual relations (1 Corinthians 6:9-11). The church cannot proclaim transforming grace while redefining as righteous what Scripture calls sin. A person changed by Christ, in turn, should care for neighbors in both spiritual and practical ways.

The Bible has consequences for public life, and Christians across the political spectrum recognize that. The question is whether Scripture gets to test our politics or is used to bless positions we have already chosen. That standard applies to the right and the left. If Talarico uses the Bible to defend progressive politics while condemning Christian nationalism among conservatives, he should explain where he draws the boundary—and why.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News