Clarence Thomas objects to California ruling he says could force citizens to speak for the government

Clarence Thomas objects to California ruling he says could force citizens to speak for the government

Justice Clarence Thomas warned Monday that the Supreme Court’s refusal to consider a challenge to a California law could leave states with room to require private citizens to express government-backed views.

The court declined to hear a case brought by California physician Azadeh Khatibi, who argued that the state’s requirements for continuing medical education courses compel instructors to discuss ideas she rejects. Thomas and Justice Samuel Alito dissented, saying the issue could extend beyond medicine.

California requires licensed doctors to complete 50 hours of approved continuing education every two years. Some courses must address implicit bias, including how it may affect medical decisions and patient outcomes, or ways to respond to its possible role in healthcare disparities.

Thomas argued that the government cannot avoid First Amendment scrutiny by labeling a message as government speech when it is actually requiring private speakers to convey the state’s position. He cautioned that the doctrine should not be used to disguise censorship or compelled expression.

Khatibi and the nonprofit Do No Harm sued California, saying the requirement forces private instructors to deliver a government-favored message. Khatibi’s lawyers said the subject was not relevant to her course topics, would take time away from them, and did not reflect her view of what drives healthcare disparities.

California says instructors are not required to endorse implicit-bias theory. They can say they disagree with it, the state argued, and explain that the topic is included to meet state requirements. California also maintained that states need broad authority to set licensing standards for doctors.

Last year, the Ninth Circuit ruled that the courses amounted to government speech because California extensively regulates the medical profession. On that basis, it found the state’s requirements were not subject to the usual First Amendment review.

Thomas disputed the idea that instructors had a genuine choice about how to present the subject. He said the requirement effectively makes them discuss implicit bias in a way that supports California’s view that it contributes to differences in health outcomes.

He also raised the possibility that the same reasoning could reach other licensed professions. For example, he asked whether California could require a speaker at a continuing-education event for lawyers to oppose racial preferences in law firm hiring. In Thomas’s view, extensive state regulation would not automatically turn a private speaker’s message into government speech outside First Amendment protection.

Justice Neil Gorsuch also favored hearing the case, but did not join the specific arguments made by Thomas and Alito. His reasons were not publicly stated.

The court’s decision leaves the Ninth Circuit ruling in place for now. It does not resolve whether California’s requirement violates the First Amendment.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News