Progressive House Democrats say the party’s new majority should make room for proposals such as slavery reparations and abolishing ICE, even as moderates warn that these priorities could pull attention from affordability.
Incoming Democratic Caucus Chairman Ted Lieu of California and other progressives said those ideas, along with expanded deportation protections, are likely to feature in legislative discussions under Speaker-nominee Hakeem Jeffries of New York. Some moderates, however, are wary of the party’s direction.
“Jeffries has been very clear, he wants to make sure everyone in the caucus is well represented,” said Rep. Sara Jacobs of California, a member of the Congressional Progressive Caucus.
Lieu said he was “excited” to discuss a wide range of proposals with caucus members, including reparations and abolishing ICE. He also said he would consider priorities raised by Rep. Ayanna Pressley of Massachusetts, such as Medicare for All, abortion rights and extending Temporary Protected Status for migrants.
Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, a prominent Democratic Socialists of America supporter, said she and Jeffries share some priorities from Pressley’s agenda, including broader access to health care and public housing.
“Of course, there are going to be areas where leader Jeffries and DSA are going to be in strong opposition,” Ocasio-Cortez said. But, she added, issues such as expanding Medicaid and addressing housing needs reflect shared values.
Ocasio-Cortez has also started working with Democratic leaders on the House Energy and Commerce Committee to advance her health care proposals, a senior congressional staffer said.
Moderate Democrats were less convinced that party leaders would adopt the progressive agenda. Some questioned whether Jeffries and other leaders had agreed to consider those demands in return for support during leadership elections.
“Our agenda is to focus on costs,” said Rep. Josh Gottheimer of New Jersey. He said Democrats had won by a wide margin and suggested some colleagues were unhappy about the party succeeding in places where it had not won before.
Gottheimer accused progressives of wanting to complain and press their demands instead of concentrating on the issues that helped Democrats win the midterms. He also rejected calls to defund police, open the borders or abolish the Senate, saying neither he nor party leaders would support those policies.
A vocal critic of the Democratic Socialists of America, Gottheimer argued that Pressley’s priorities were closer to the group’s platform than to the broader Democratic agenda. “The DSA, they have their own agenda,” he said.
Another Democratic lawmaker, speaking anonymously, called it “crazy” to think party leaders would adopt the progressive platform. The lawmaker also suggested Lieu and Jeffries were signaling openness to those proposals to avoid opposition in the leadership elections.
Jeffries and Pressley did not respond to requests for comment.






