Michigan Sen.-elect Abdul El-Sayed brushed aside concerns that his criticism of Israel could contribute to antisemitism in an interview with The Atlantic on Tuesday. He has called Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu a war criminal and accused Israel of committing genocide during the war in Gaza.
Asked what he would say to people who fear his remarks could fuel antisemitism, El-Sayed said he did not want anyone to feel threatened. But he suggested that some reactions might be about discomfort rather than personal safety.
El-Sayed said people should not be put in danger because of his comments. At the same time, he argued, discomfort with criticism of Israel is different from a genuine threat. He said he would not stay silent while people were killed and homes, hospitals and universities in Gaza were destroyed, adding that their humanity should not count for less than anyone else’s.
Asked what Israel should be as a nation, El-Sayed said it should guarantee equal rights to all its citizens and protect their freedom under the law. He also said the country should not define itself through a single culture or faith, describing these principles as part of peace, dignity and self-determination.
El-Sayed has faced criticism over previous comments about Israel, including his reluctance to say whether he believes the country has a right to exist.
Rabbi Yaakov Menken, executive vice president of the Coalition for Jewish Values, called El-Sayed’s remarks “outrageous and hateful.” Menken accused him of condemning efforts to fight Hamas, which he described as a terrorist organization. He said El-Sayed characterized the destruction of Hamas tunnels and the rescue of civilians from torture, sexual assault and murder as an injustice.
El-Sayed’s team was contacted for comment.






