‘Enough’: Protesters speak out against antisemitism after Hunter College cancels student event that included a Jewish group

‘Enough’: Protesters speak out against antisemitism after Hunter College cancels student event that included a Jewish group

People gathered outside Hunter College on Thursday to protest the cancellation of a campus event that had included a Jewish student organization.

Pro-Israel demonstrators stood on one side of the street, waving American and Israeli flags and chanting “enough is enough” as speakers addressed the crowd. On the other side, counter-protesters waved Palestinian flags and chanted. Some passersby joined in, expressing support for one side or shouting “Free Palestine” and “F— Israel.”

The rally, called Stand with Jewish Students at Hunter, was organized by the Israeli American Council, Students Supporting Israel and #EndJewHatred. Event flyers accused the college administration of failing to respond adequately to what organizers described as antisemitism.

Israeli American Council CEO Elan Carr said the rally was intended to push back against what he viewed as the exclusion of Jewish students and hostility toward Jewish life, including the campus Hillel group and Israel.

Michelle Ahdoot, #EndJewHatred’s director of programming and strategy, said the cancellation reflected a broader concern. Multicultural events, she said, should welcome different communities rather than leave decisions about who belongs to individual groups. Organizations can choose whether to participate, she added, but canceling an entire event instead of ensuring Jewish students are included risks suggesting their participation is unwelcome.

Cultural Arts Night was scheduled for Nov. 16 but was called off a few days beforehand. Screenshots of flyers shared online showed that participating groups were to include Students for Justice in Palestine, the Peruvian Student Association, the Hunter Chinese Student and Scholar Association, the Taiwanese Student Association and Hunter Hillel.

Hillel International operates on college campuses around the world and describes itself as a welcoming space for Jewish students. Its work centers on Jewish life and culture, including holidays and events, while also encouraging students to engage with Jewish learning and Israel.

Rita Levine Rabin Hillel at Hunter College said on Instagram that it had been looking forward to Cultural Arts Night and was not involved in the decision to cancel it. The group said antisemitism had no place at the college and that Jewish students should not be singled out or made to feel unwelcome. It also condemned antisemitic reactions to the cancellation online.

Ilya Bratman, executive director of Hillel at Baruch College, called the decision antisemitic and warned that excluding Jewish students could be an early sign of a worsening campus climate. He argued that the issue was hostility toward Jews, not disagreement over Israel, and said universities needed to take the matter seriously.

Hunter College Undergraduate Student Government announced the cancellation on Nov. 14 in a statement from President Sumaiya Ahmed and Vice President Ahmad Waraich. They said communication failures had prevented the event’s details from reaching senior student government officials.

The student government said it had listened to students and decided the event did not reflect the values of the organization or the Hunter community. It apologized to the clubs and students affected.

After the announcement, some people speculated that anti-Israel activists had pressured the student government to cancel because Hillel was participating. The student government did not directly address that claim, but later said the decision had been made over safety concerns.

Hunter is part of the public City University of New York system. The college said it was troubled by reports that student groups had withdrawn because of Hillel’s involvement and that it was looking into the matter. It added that discrimination and harassment were prohibited and that its policies would be enforced.

Michal Mari, president of Students Supporting Israel at Hunter, said Jewish students faced a difficult atmosphere on campus. She cited calls for violence, including slogans about bringing the war home and globalizing the intifada. Mari said she believed the event was canceled after clubs withdrew over Hillel’s participation, which she described as discrimination against Jewish students.

Mari also said she had experienced professors turning away from her after noticing her Star of David necklace or learning she had been to Israel. The campus was not, in her view, the most divided, but she said there was still work to do.

Mari spoke at Thursday’s rally alongside other pro-Israel and Jewish speakers, including Shai Davidai, Ari Ackerman, Shabbos Kestenbaum and Rami Matan Even-Esh, known as Kosha Dillz, as well as Hunter students.

Jayne Zirkle, communications director for #EndJewHatred, praised students who spoke publicly despite the pressure they face on campus. She said they should know they had support and were not alone.

Davidai, a former Columbia University professor, said he attended to draw attention to what he saw as a wider problem. Canceling an event because a Jewish group is involved, he argued, affects everyone who might have attended, not only Jewish students.

Kestenbaum, a former Harvard Divinity School student who sued Harvard over antisemitism on campus, focused on the legal questions. He said universities receiving public support must comply with civil rights law and cannot discriminate against students because of their ethnicity or religion.

New York City Council Member Eric Dinowitz also called for an investigation. In a post on X, he said the cancellation appeared to be another troubling episode in the history of antisemitism at CUNY and Hunter, and urged CUNY to begin a Title VI investigation.

Speakers at the rally urged students not to withdraw from campus life or stay quiet. Davidai said students who spoke up would have support, including legal help and public backing. Mari offered a similar message, saying the Jewish community would stand behind students who chose to speak out, even if they felt afraid.

Hunter USG and Hunter Hillel did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News