Allegations of Hazing and Assault in Lawsuit Against St. Joseph’s Baseball Team

A former teammate from St. Joseph’s baseball team has initiated a lawsuit claiming he was subjected to severe humiliation and physical assault in March.

The lawsuit was filed Monday in state Supreme Court in Suffolk County. It alleges a “pattern of harassment, bullying, physical assault, humiliation, retaliation, negligent supervision and systemic misconduct” among members of the varsity baseball team. Reports suggest that around 30 unidentified players took part in the hazing, which was acknowledged by head coach Thomas Caputo and assistant coach Elliott Robles.

The complaint states that “teammates forced their soiled underwear on the plaintiff’s face and physically assaulted him.” It further claims the plaintiff experienced humiliation, intimidation, and threats to his safety while trying to defend himself during the physical altercation.

This incident is reported to have taken place on March 5th while the team was en route to a game in Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.

The complaint also argues that proper oversight was lacking during this event, despite Robles asserting he conducted room checks and oversaw the players.

According to court filings, an investigation involving Caputo and Robles supported the victim’s account, suggesting that both were aware the plaintiff was not the aggressor.

While the complaint suggests that Mr. Caputo and Mr. Robles promised a thorough investigation, the plaintiff’s attorney, Mike Della, noted that his client faced suspension while others involved received no disciplinary action. The plaintiff has begun to transfer schools and is contemplating leaving baseball altogether.

The university released a statement emphasizing that it “takes seriously the concerns raised by community members” and acknowledged the ongoing litigation. They expressed their inability to comment in detail, asserting that they strongly disagree with the allegations and will address them in the legal process.