GOING SOUTH: College culture focused on progressive ideas has spread into the South

GOING SOUTH: College culture focused on progressive ideas has spread into the South

Southern colleges have lately been promoted as alternatives to northern universities seen as strongly progressive. Some families, it seems, hope a move south will offer students a less “woke” version of higher education.

That has led some students to consider Vanderbilt, Duke, Georgia, Alabama, or Florida instead of Ivy League schools or their nearby state universities. The assumption is that the South is more traditional and conservative, so its colleges must be as well.

On a recent visit to Nashville, I stopped by Vanderbilt, one of the region’s best-known universities, to see whether that assumption held up.

Greek life

I started around Greek Row. It wasn’t quite what I expected. Vanderbilt’s fraternity and sorority houses were mostly plain brick buildings, not grand old Southern homes or Tudor-style houses.

One fraternity had a faded “PARTY TONIGHT” banner draped across the front. It looked as though it might have been there for weeks. Empty beer and energy-drink cans were scattered over the lawn.

That certainly felt like a familiar kind of college scene, though it wasn’t especially appealing.

The Women’s Center

As I continued across campus, I came across the Margaret Cuninggim Women’s Center, founded in 1978. The name is spelled exactly that way.

When it opened, perhaps a women’s center helped address the male-dominated atmosphere of college life. I wondered how necessary it is today, given that women make up a majority of students at Vanderbilt—56%, according to the figure I saw.

At the student center

The student center gave me my first chance to see a large number of Vanderbilt students in one place. They seemed studious, and, honestly, a little unremarkable. On a warm October day, most were wearing the standard combination of shorts and T-shirts.

I looked around for event flyers and posters. Those can offer a quick sense of what campus life is like. But I didn’t spot bulletin boards or kiosks, or announcements for parties, trivia nights, hiking groups, or knitting circles. Maybe I missed them, but I found the absence surprising.

A campus snapshot

Vanderbilt seemed demographically similar to other highly ranked American universities. My rough impression was that about a third of the students were white, with the rest identifying as Asian, Indian, Arab, or another background.

I noticed students gathering in groups: Indian men joking together, for instance, and Asian women talking as they studied. Nearby, one white student sat alone with a burrito, looking at his phone. It made me wonder whether white students were less inclined to form groups with one another, or whether they felt awkward doing so in a diverse campus environment. I couldn’t really know from a quick visit.

It also struck me that students who share a background may find it easier to connect. An elite private university offers plenty to look forward to—green spaces, academic opportunities, and promising career paths. Many students are preparing for fields such as science, finance, law, or medicine, and may feel they have found a place where they can build a future.

I also noticed a young white woman sitting by herself with a gender studies textbook. I caught myself wondering what her prospects might be, though that was an unfair amount to infer from a single glance. The scene left me with a somewhat bleak impression of how students might be sorting themselves out socially.

Belonging and community

I kept looking for signs of ordinary campus activities. There had to be more than I was seeing. I came across a Student Wellbeing Lounge, where a first-year student had just woken from a nap and was disentangling himself from a blanket in a beanbag chair.

At the Center for Belonging and Community, I saw several young women wearing hijabs and eating salads. Farther into the student center was the Office of Student Accountability, Community Standards, and Academic Integrity—a name that takes a moment to get through.

Awareness month

Eventually, I found a poster. It announced that October was Dating and Domestic Violence Awareness Month and listed activities planned on campus.

Devoting a whole month to the issue didn’t match my idea of a traditional college experience. To me, it suggested a campus culture focused heavily on contemporary social concerns. I found myself wondering whether that emphasis was helpful awareness-raising or something more alarmist.

Reporting concerns

Later that day, I looked through Vanderbilt’s official website. Much of it focused on mental health, students in crisis, empathy, and connecting people with support.

I also found online forms that allow people to report concerns about other students, including anonymously. The list covered issues such as sexual harassment, assault, misconduct, stalking, hazing, bias incidents, and hate speech.

There was also space to describe other kinds of harm. The examples included invasion of personal space, offensive jokes, suggestive staring, expressing unpopular opinions, and making someone uncomfortable.

Faculty and staff could submit reports, too. There are plenty of employees on a modern college campus, so the system could involve more than just students. Still, seeing such a broad reporting process made me wonder how often students might use it to report one another for behavior they found unwelcome.

What’s your major?

I also browsed Vanderbilt’s undergraduate course catalogue. Many subjects that can be approached through a political lens appeared to include familiar themes around oppression, racism, sexism, and LGBTQ issues. I saw that in literature, history, and American Studies courses.

From what I found, Vanderbilt did not seem to be setting itself apart from progressive northern universities by offering a more traditional academic culture. In that respect, it appeared to be following a similar path.

In conclusion

Perhaps Hillsdale College, or a small Christian school somewhere in the mountains, offers a clearer alternative to what I think of as “Woke College USA.” But Vanderbilt did not feel like an escape from the left-leaning language and ideas I had expected to find at northern campuses. If anything, it seemed full of them.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News