GOP strategists point to populism as fuel for Republican tax hike talk

The aversion to tax hikes has long been one of the Republican core pillars, but tradition has been eclipsed over recent weeks as the new billionaire potential billionaires are being debated as Capitol Hill debate.

The Republican operatives who spoke to Fox News Digital were not very surprised, but were baffling some members of the old GOP security guards. They said these conversations were led primarily by the party’s growing populist wings.

“I don’t know if I’m surprised anymore because the party has changed so much in a short period of time. But that’s worth noting,” longtime GOP strategist Doug Hay told Fox News Digital.

Hay recalled his time as a senior House leadership aide in 2012. I recall that in 2012 the Republican proposal for people under $1 million a year “exploded by raising taxes by insurrections within our own ranks.

The White House quietly floats billionaires tax collection proposals in Congress to let GOP leaders know their opposition

“It all exploded in our faces,” he said. “And now, this is something we want to do more and more of the Republicans who rejected the idea in 2012.”

Sources told Fox News Digital this month that the White House is socializing plans among Republicans and creating a new 40% tax bracket for those making more than $1 million.

Various reported plans that emerged among House Republicans included tax hikes ranging from 38% to 40%, an ultra-rich tax rate.

Former House Speaker Newt Ginrich posted a message this week from President Donald Trump himself, saying, “If you can without that, it’s better to try and do so.”

Fox News Digital reached out to the White House Wednesday morning, commenting on Gingrich’s memo, including the context of the message and the reason Trump explained he “loves” the tax increase, but received no response.

Currently, the highest income tax rate is $609,351 per person’s revenue, and about 37% at $731,201 for married couples. Trump’s 2017 Tax Cuts and Employment Act has now dropped just above 39%.

“Politics is a good place to raise taxes for wealthy Americans,” said John Feehelly, partner at EFB Advocacy and a veteran of House GOP Leadership Staff. “The downside is that it affects economic growth. So if you need a cheap political score, that’s the way. On the other hand, if you need a solid economy where people work, you want to be aware of how you do it.”

Asked if the argument caught him off guard, Feehery said, “Trump is such a populist and he has a lot of populists, so I’m not surprised by that.”

He presented a higher tax appeal against the wealthy people born of that shift.

“When you look at the biggest constituency, the constituency, it’s really interesting because the parties have kind of made a difference,” he continued. “A formerly a rural Republican and a working-class Democrat. I’m now a working-class Republican and a country club Democrat.”

When asked about the increase in tax hike talks, Hay said, “I think it’s a mix of Trump and populism.”

Former House Speaker Newt Gingrich opposes tax hikes for the wealthy. (Reuters/Mike Segar/File)

“To raise taxes for Republicans was once a disgust for Republicans. When George Bush did it after saying, ‘Read my lips,’ it was the beginning of his presidential end,” Hay said. “That world doesn’t exist anymore.”

House GOP leaders have publicly made it clear that they are opposed to raising taxes for everyone. But Republicans have to find a way to pass Trump’s budget, including a new tax policy that eliminates chip and overtime wage obligations.

Andy Harris, R-Md, Chair of House Freedom Caucus. had previously shown that he was open to ideas if spending cuts were not reachable by other means.

“What I want to do is actually find spending cuts elsewhere in my budget, but if I don’t get enough spending cuts, I’ll have to pay for the tax cut,” Harris told “Morning with Maria” at Fox Business last week.

Scoop: Pence urges Republicans to keep a line of tax hikes for the rich as Trump considers options

“Before the Tax Cuts and Employment Act, the highest tax range was 39.6%. That was under $1 million. Ideally, what we can do – again, if we can’t find a reduction in spending, “OK, let’s recover that high bracket.

Rep. Dan Meuser, R-Pa. Similarly, there was a view to raising the top tax bracket to 38.6%.

He later told Fox News Digital in a statement: “I believe the President must fulfill his promise of tax and regulatory plans to help pro-Americans grow their economy and manufacturing, and help them provide the majority of Americans.

Both Meuser and Harris declined to provide more comments on this story.

Former Vice President Mike Pence, who calls the 2017 tax cuts “Trump Pence’s tax cuts,” urged House Republicans last week to stick to the country’s top earners’ tax hikes and make the 2017 tax cuts permanent.

Rep. Dan Meuser’s R-Pa. said tax “adjustments” should be considered to pass Trump’s agenda. (Tom Williams/CQ Roll Call by Getty Images)

One House GOP MP told Fox News Digital last week that the response to the increased response among colleagues was “mixed.”

However, former Republican members were skeptical on Wednesday.

“Tax cuts are short-term highs and ultimately do more harm than good,” the former House Republican said. “This strategy goes against conservative values.”

Click here to get the Fox News app

Meanwhile, Mark Goldvine, senior policy director at the Nonpartisan Committee for Responsible Federal Budget, said it is “health” that lawmakers entertain financial ideas outside of party norms.

However, he was wary of promoting tax increases.

“I’m not a fan of doing things that are actually bad financially and that look financially good…and on top of that, I think raising tax rates is not the best way to make money,” Goldwine said. “But with these two being said, I think it’s a very healthy move to be talking about things like GOP that can actually go in both directions.”

Fox News Digital reached out to Gingrich for an interview for this story but did not receive a response.

Emma Colton of Fox News Digital contributed to this report.