Half of California’s district attorneys sue Newsom over clemency for death row inmates

Newsom introduces crime teams in California after criticizing Trump for ‘militarizing cities’

District attorneys from 29 of California’s 58 counties have joined victims’ families and law enforcement groups in a lawsuit challenging Gov. Gavin Newsom’s decision to commute the death sentences of 548 inmates. The petition argues that the term-limited governor’s action failed to follow required procedures and exceeded his authority.

Many prosecutors criticized Newsom’s decision soon after he announced it. Former Sacramento District Attorney Anne Marie Schubert, who filed the 58-page petition Monday, says the mass commutations bypassed legally required notice to victims’ families and prosecutors. She also argues they interfered with the California Supreme Court’s review of the cases.

Schubert, now president and CEO of the Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, said she worked through the weekend on the filing. The foundation is bringing the case on behalf of the 29 district attorneys and families of more than two dozen victims.

Among the petitioners is Marc Klaas, whose 12-year-old daughter, Polly, was kidnapped from a slumber party and murdered in 1993. Her killer, Richard Allen Davis, has been on death row since 1996.

Other families connected to the case include relatives of Gabriel Fernandez, 8; Placer County Sheriff’s Detective Mike Davis; Pittsburg Police Officer Larry Lasater; Sacramento Deputy Danny Paul Oliver; and five U.S. Forest Service firefighters killed while battling the Esperanza Fire in 2006.

Schubert wrote that the commutations could have an especially severe effect on families who have endured years of grief. She also challenged Newsom’s assurance that the inmates would never be released, calling it false.

The dispute has drawn attention from the White House. President Donald Trump, Attorney General Todd Blanche and FBI Director Kash Patel were expected to meet with some of the victims’ families on Monday.

White House spokeswoman Lauren Bis accused Newsom of failing victims and their families, and said Trump would continue to support them and prioritize public safety.

California has not carried out an execution in 20 years, despite having the country’s largest death row. Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra is expected to maintain the state’s execution moratorium after taking office. The death penalty remains part of state law, however, and condemned inmates are excluded from some criminal justice reforms.

Newsom has said the prisoners covered by his decision cannot benefit from other reforms that might further reduce their sentences or lead to their release. His office did not immediately respond to a request for comment on the lawsuit.

Orange County District Attorney Todd Spitzer, who filed a separate petition Monday, has warned that inmates could move closer to further sentence reductions as the state’s execution moratorium continues.

In an open letter to Californians, Newsom said the state could not morally execute the hundreds of people on death row. He argued that state-sanctioned executions conflict with California’s values and weaken the justice system, while acknowledging that the inmates’ crimes had caused profound suffering.

The California Supreme Court is expected to review at least 382 cases involving inmates convicted of multiple felonies before the commutations take effect. Schubert’s filing says the state may not have identified every inmate who meets the review criteria and suggests Newsom’s list could have been based on incomplete criminal records.

Some legal experts say the lawsuit faces a difficult path. Neama Rahmani, a Los Angeles trial lawyer and former federal prosecutor, said governors have broad authority to commute sentences and grant pardons, leaving prosecutors and victims with limited options to stop such decisions.

Rahmani also said California’s victims’ rights law, which provides for advance notice of certain clemency and parole decisions, may not apply because the inmates did not submit formal applications.

Schubert’s filing argues that allowing the lack of an application to bypass the law would create an unfair outcome: inmates who follow standard procedures would face oversight, while broader actions affecting other prisoners would not.

She noted that thousands of jurors and hundreds of judges took part in the convictions and death sentences involved, often setting aside personal views to apply the law. Schubert argued that Newsom had overridden their work based on his own beliefs and said that amounted to an abuse of power.

The Death Penalty Information Center says Newsom had not granted clemency to a death row inmate before this month’s announcement, despite his longstanding opposition to capital punishment. No California governor had commuted a death sentence since Ronald Reagan did so in 1967 for a man later found to have previously undiagnosed brain damage.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News