Co-host stunned as Hostin supports Gavin Newsom reducing death row inmates’ sentences without involving victims’ families

Co-host stunned as Hostin supports Gavin Newsom reducing death row inmates’ sentences without involving victims’ families

“The View” co-host Ana Navarro pushed back after Sunny Hostin disagreed with her view that California Gov. Gavin Newsom should have informed victims’ families before commuting the death sentences of 548 people.

Navarro said she objected to the way the decision was made. She argued that the families should have been consulted, noting that the people affected had been convicted of murder and were on death row. She also said she opposes blanket pardons and believes decisions like these should be considered individually.

Newsom commuted the sentences of every person on California’s death row in early November, effectively ending capital punishment in the state. He had previously imposed a moratorium on executions.

Navarro said families should not have to learn from news reports that the sentence in their loved one’s case had changed. Hostin disagreed, saying she opposes the death penalty and believes no one should be executed under a system she considers flawed.

Hostin argued that even one innocent person being executed would be too high a price. She also cited statistics she said show that Black people are overrepresented among those exonerated from death row and among people whose murder convictions were overturned after wrongful convictions were identified by the Innocence Project.

Co-host Alyssa Farah Griffin agreed with Navarro, saying the families should have been notified in advance. While she acknowledged that Newsom had the authority to commute the sentences, Griffin said the lack of notice added to families’ grief. She also suggested the decision could have political implications, saying Newsom may be seeking to appeal to progressive voters as he considers a presidential run.

Sara Haines also supported a case-by-case approach. She said California voters had chosen to retain the death penalty and argued that commuting every sentence at once treated families’ experiences as though they were all the same. For some families, she added, the conviction and sentence had provided at least a measure of closure.

Newsom’s office directed inquiries to a letter explaining his decision. In it, the governor called the choice one of the most difficult of his career, saying he understood that the announcement could bring painful memories back for victims’ families. He said he respected those who disagreed with him, including families who had suffered devastating losses.

Newsom also described the decision as necessary, saying he believes society is stronger when it rejects state-sanctioned killing. He noted that California voters had kept the death penalty in place and said his action did not repeal it. The authority to abolish capital punishment, he wrote, belongs to the Legislature and voters.

Y. David Scharf, chairman of Morrison Cohen LLP, criticized the decision, saying victims’ rights had been disregarded. He said families deserved more than to discover that sentences in their loved ones’ cases had been changed as part of a sweeping decision affecting hundreds of people. Even if the governor had the constitutional authority to act, Scharf said, families should have received notice and an opportunity to be heard.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News