The Justice Department has issued more than 200 subpoenas as part of a criminal investigation into Dan J. Sullivan, known as “Decoy Dan,” who ran against Republican Sen. Dan S. Sullivan in Alaska’s U.S. Senate race.
The investigation’s scale became public after Democrat Mary Peltola was declared the winner of the four-way election Tuesday night, two weeks after Election Day. She received 144,302 votes, compared with 131,844 for the incumbent senator. Republican Gerald Heikes received 6,105 votes, while the unaffiliated Sullivan collected 4,760.
A law enforcement source said the investigation is ongoing and that Peltola’s win has not changed its direction. The probe involves multiple states and several criminal targets, the source said. Another person familiar with the case confirmed that more than 200 subpoenas have been issued.
The investigation follows allegations that Democrats sought out someone named Dan Sullivan to challenge the sitting senator, potentially confusing voters and weakening Republican support.
Marc Elias, a prominent Democratic attorney whose firm represents Peltola’s campaign, received a criminal target letter from the Justice Department earlier this month.
The controversy intensified days before the Nov. 3, 2026, midterm election, after reports said Peltola campaign aides, the Democratic Senatorial Campaign Committee and political operatives from outside Alaska had taken part in what they called a “ballot composition project.” The reported aim was to recruit another Dan Sullivan to enter the race.
Peltola’s campaign and the DSCC have denied wrongdoing.
“Decoy Dan” is a retired teacher from Petersburg, a small island community in southeast Alaska. He had little visible presence on the campaign trail; some neighbors said they had not seen campaign materials from him. His campaign raised $35,556.
Peltola, a former state lawmaker, made history in 2022 as the first Alaska Native elected to Congress. She lost her seat in 2024 to Republican Rep. Nick Begich.
Alaska election officials initially sought to remove the second Sullivan from the ballot amid claims his candidacy was meant to confuse voters or draw votes away from the senator. Sullivan denied wrongdoing, and the Alaska Supreme Court ruled he could remain on the ballot.
In October, the Justice Department filed a lawsuit seeking to limit what it described as the potentially misleading effect of Sullivan’s candidacy.
President Donald Trump urged Peltola to leave the race and criticized Democrats over the alleged effort.
“You had the Democrat Party headed up by Elias, their lawyer, who was a bad guy, very bad guy — should go to jail, in my opinion,” Trump said on Election Day. “But you had the Democrat Party look all over Alaska for somebody named Sullivan.”
Peltola’s and Sullivan’s campaigns, as well as the DSCC, did not respond to requests for comment. The White House pointed to Trump’s earlier remarks about the case.






