New religious freedom rankings show an unexpected divide among states as a legal expert warns of expensive burdens

New religious freedom rankings show an unexpected divide among states as a legal expert warns of expensive burdens

Michigan ranks last in the country for legal protections affecting faith-based nonprofits, while Alabama ranks first, according to the 2026 Faith and Freedom Index from Napa Legal Institute. The report points to some notable differences between states led by Republicans and Democrats.

Released Monday, the index examines laws in all 50 states and Washington, D.C., that affect religious organizations, including churches, religious schools, pregnancy resource centers and homeless shelters.

Michigan received an overall score of 34%, with Washington at 38% and Massachusetts at 41%. Napa Legal senior counsel Frank DeVito said Michigan’s low ranking reflects what he considers burdensome nondiscrimination rules, limited religious exemptions and regulatory hurdles for faith-based groups.

DeVito said the state’s laws may make it difficult for Catholic schools and other religious institutions to make hiring and admissions decisions in keeping with their beliefs. He also criticized financial reporting requirements that he said can be costly for religious nonprofits, leaving fewer resources for education, charity and support for vulnerable communities.

Alabama topped the rankings with 80%. Kansas followed at 76%, Indiana at 75% and Texas at 71%.

Some of the results, though, don’t follow the usual political pattern. New York scored higher overall than Republican-led North Dakota, South Carolina and Tennessee. In some areas, traditionally conservative states also ranked below Democratic-led ones.

DeVito said New York has broader exemptions from certain nondiscrimination laws in employment and public programs than Tennessee. He also pointed to a state court decision finding that New York’s constitution offers greater protection for religious exercise than the federal First Amendment.

The report argues that state laws can have a substantial effect on religious organizations’ ability to operate—not just decisions from the Supreme Court or Congress.

Napa Legal said a number of states have strengthened protections for faith-based nonprofits in recent years. Florida, for example, updated its nonprofit corporation laws to clarify that directors of religious organizations may consult faith leaders, including priests, ministers and rabbis, on religious matters.

Massachusetts and Rhode Island have also eased some nonprofit financial reporting rules. Massachusetts raised the annual revenue level that triggers a required independent audit from $200,000 to $500,000. Rhode Island doubled its threshold, from $500,000 to $1 million, according to the institute.

DeVito said lawmakers should establish durable protections for religious organizations because of the services they provide, including educating children and helping people in need.

He warned that regulations and expensive legal disputes can pull time and money away from those organizations’ work. DeVito urged lawmakers in both parties to strengthen religious liberty protections, including exemptions from some nondiscrimination rules and tax requirements, even when those changes may be politically or financially difficult.

Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer’s office was asked to comment on the report but did not immediately respond.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News