Michael Anton’s now-famous “Flight 93” essay appeared two months before Donald Trump’s first election victory in 2016. Anton argued that conservatives had to take a desperate gamble rather than accept what he saw as certain defeat. But even if their candidate made it into the cockpit, he might not know how to land the plane.
Ten years on, Trump is at the controls, and the American right is buckled in behind him. He seems determined to put the whole enterprise at risk. Passengers are calling out the turbulence. Almost no one is willing to confront the pilot.
How much more are Republicans prepared to lose by treating one man as a cause worth going down with?
The gamble made a harsh sort of sense in 2016. Many voters were fed up with a Republican establishment that promised to fight, then governed as if change were impossible. But backing Trump never had to mean obeying him forever. A movement that cannot challenge its own leader is not much of a movement.
After the midterm defeat, I asked how Republicans could recover while Trump continued to control their public image, messaging, endorsements, fundraising, and party machinery. His answer has been to double down on the very things voters had just rejected: an extravagant White House ballroom, tariffs, the war with Iran, a stock-market-focused economy that does little for renters, and more data centers. Even as Nvidia CEO Jensen Huang faced a national-security controversy, Trump supported the idea of restoring him to his job.
Trump is choosing the wrong fights while neglecting the concerns that helped bring him to power in 2016. He has also indicated he may be willing to strike a deal with Democrats on immigration. Is this really the course correction Republicans were waiting for?
Then came a claim that surprised even me: Trump insisted the Democrats’ sweeping victory had been stolen. On Sunday, he said the 2026 midterms were rigged, arguing that counties in Texas and Kansas shifting toward Democrats was impossible and demanding an immediate investigation into what he called fraud.
It seems he cannot accept that millions of voters considered his record and rejected it. Rather than reckon with the election result, Trump is offering his supporters another conspiracy theory.
The scale of the loss should alarm Republicans. Democrats won the overall U.S. House vote in Indiana, a state Trump carried comfortably in 2024. Republicans had only narrow leads in Utah and Missouri. And once the newly elected governors take office, Democratic governors will lead states home to about three-quarters of the country’s population.
These are not the results of a party that is one staff shake-up away from recovery. They do not become less real because the president posts about voting machines in the middle of the night.
Think about a Republican candidate trying to win back a suburban district. How can she talk about the cost of living when Trump’s daily declarations drown out the message? How can she promise capable government while the president celebrates monuments to himself? The national party’s reputation follows every local candidate into the voting booth.
Mr. President, the unprecedented problem here is your own conduct. Republicans can replace White House staff, congressional leaders, and even their legislative priorities. None of that will be enough if the president keeps pointing to rising investment portfolios as proof that the economy is thriving while younger Americans struggle to afford a home.
There is more at stake. Republicans face a difficult Senate map in 2028, including races in states where the party has just suffered major setbacks. A weaker economy would make things worse. What if the AI boom fades or the housing market breaks? It is hard to imagine Trump becoming more measured and responsive as the pressure grows.
The potential successors have little to offer by way of an answer. Many conservatives appear ready to make Vice President JD Vance the 2028 nominee. But how would choosing Trump’s deputy convince voters that the party has listened to their concerns about Trump himself?
Much of the conservative commentary, meanwhile, is focused on finding someone else to blame: congressional Republicans, presidential advisers, candidates accused of disloyalty. Anyone but Trump. There is plenty of talk about unity, but also an unwritten rule against criticizing the man who is pushing away voters the party needs to win back.
In 2016, Trump’s refusal to listen to critics could look like strength. By 2026, that same instinct has become an inability to learn from defeat. He praises the ballroom as families worry about prices, boasts about Big Tech as its investments threaten to reshape communities, and alleges fraud when voters turn against him. His defenders call it fighting.
The next two years will not be a quiet stretch. Democrats will control Congress, while Trump will continue to dominate the Republican Party’s attention and the news cycle. Republican candidates will be left defending whatever new controversy he creates. The right cannot rebuild while its leader keeps tearing down the structure.
Anton wrote about a last-chance test of political survival. Now the test is facing the right itself. Can it separate its principles from the fortunes of the man who took control of the party? Can it acknowledge that the person once seen as a rescuer may now be the biggest obstacle to recovery?
The plane is losing altitude. Passengers can keep cursing the weather, blaming the ground crew, and praising the pilot’s courage. Or they can do what the Flight 93 metaphor called for from the beginning: confront the person in the cockpit.
How much more are Republicans willing to lose by treating one man as a cause worth going down with?



