Is Mark Carney choosing China instead of making a trade deal with Trump?

Is Mark Carney choosing China instead of making a trade deal with Trump?

Carney’s China ties could complicate trade talks with Trump

Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney may be putting another potential trade agreement with President Donald Trump at risk as he deepens Canada’s relationship with China.

U.S. Ambassador to Canada Pete Hoekstra said in October that Carney had twice turned down what he described as the best deal Canada could expect from the Trump administration.

Carney has argued that the proposed agreement could undermine Canadian sovereignty and put French-language protections and Quebec culture at risk. U.S. officials have rejected those concerns. Carney, however, has not publicly shared the deal’s details with Canadians.

Now, his closer engagement with Beijing is adding another complication to negotiations with Washington.

Tariff trouble

In January, Carney struck an agreement with China that allows up to 49,000 Chinese electric vehicles into Canada each year at a 6.1% tariff. The arrangement exempts them from the additional 100% tariff Canada imposed in 2024. In return, China agreed to reduce tariffs on Canadian agricultural goods.

Trump warned that he could impose a 100% tariff on Canadian products if Canada pursued a broader trade agreement with China.

In July, U.S. Trade Representative Jamieson Greer also raised concerns about Canada’s growing economic ties with Beijing as the United States resisted renewing the existing North American trade pact. Greer cautioned that Chinese automakers might use Canadian facilities to reach the U.S. market and get around measures meant to protect American manufacturers and workers.

Carney is now suggesting that Canada could attract still more Chinese investment in its auto industry.

Action and reaction

On November 16, Carney said Canada might turn to Chinese automakers if talks with Washington fail to preserve an integrated North American auto industry. He said any investment would have to include significant manufacturing in Canada, rather than just assembling vehicles brought in from elsewhere.

Asked whether the prospect of Chinese investment was intended to pressure Washington, Carney said it was not leverage, but a matter of “action, reaction.”

He maintained that reaching an agreement with the United States remained his priority. Still, he made clear that Canada would look at other options if negotiations did not succeed.

“Canada is going to move forward either way,” he said.

Risky business

Carney has also ventured into sensitive territory with comments about the security risks of Canada’s partnership with China.

On November 10, he compared the risks of Canada’s relationship with Beijing with those connected to the United States’ own dealings with China.

Carney said he would meet Chinese President Xi Jinping at the APEC summit and discuss global security and the countries’ expanding economic relationship. He added that the partnership had clear limits on the areas in which the two countries would work together.

He then said the security risks tied to Canada’s partnership with China were “much, much, much, much less” than those facing the United States.

The remarks prompted criticism that Carney viewed the United States as a greater security threat than China. His comparison, though, appeared to refer to risks arising from each country’s economic relationship with Beijing.

The comments echoed Carney’s past criticism of U.S. policy, including his references to the War of 1812 while responding to American threats involving Canadian sovereignty, and his sharp remarks about U.S. economic policy at the World Economic Forum.

A new world order

Carney has openly supported closer ties with China as he has criticized the United States. During a January 2026 visit to Beijing, he welcomed a renewed strategic partnership with the Chinese government and spoke of a “new world order.”

He said the progress made in the partnership had put the two countries in a good position for the changing global landscape.

His comments drew criticism from people who questioned why Canada’s prime minister was eager to strengthen ties with Beijing while relations with Washington were worsening.

Carney’s support for a larger role for China in international finance goes back several years, including to his time as governor of the Bank of England. He has argued that the U.S. dollar should have less influence in the global financial system and that China’s currency, the renminbi, should play a greater international role.

Alternative currencies

In a March 2024 interview with a Chinese business publication, Carney said the global reserve-currency system should better reflect China’s growing place in the world economy.

He described wider use of the renminbi as an important step toward making it a reserve currency, while noting that China would need to make its currency more freely convertible and open its capital markets further.

Carney made a similar case in 2019 at the Jackson Hole Economic Symposium, during Trump’s first presidency. As Trump imposed tariffs on China and clashed with Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell over interest rates, Carney called for a more diverse international monetary system to reduce the dollar’s dominance. He also raised the idea of a “synthetic hegemonic currency.”

Carney argued that the dollar’s central role in trade and finance could expose other countries to economic disruptions that began in the United States. A stronger dollar, he said, could tighten financial conditions elsewhere even when local economic circumstances did not call for it.

He proposed greater international cooperation on monetary policy and, over time, a system less reliant on the dollar. A synthetic currency, he said, could reduce the dollar’s outsized influence on global trade.

Carney also considered whether the renminbi might eventually become a major reserve currency, though he said it still had a long way to go. He pointed to China’s status as the world’s leading trading nation and the growing use of its currency internationally.

Rather than replace the dollar with the renminbi, Carney advocated a multipolar system in which several currencies could share international influence.

Seven years later, Carney is Canada’s prime minister, pursuing closer economic ties with Beijing while trying to reach a trade agreement with Washington. Whether his approach to China will cost him another deal with Trump remains uncertain.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News