In recent years, some Democrats have compared redistricting efforts to the Holocaust, describing them as a “threat to democracy” and labeling their opponents as “authoritarians.” Yet, as Virginia approaches its gerrymandering referendum, the Democrats’ stance appears inconsistent.
When the party managed to secure 10 out of the state’s 11 congressional seats, they began to view gerrymandering more favorably, calling it a tool to “level the playing field.” Virginia Democratic Governor Abigail Spanberger stated, “This is a response to what we’re seeing in other states that are taking extreme measures to undermine democratic norms.” The push was aimed at “restoring fairness” in the electoral process.
Aided by significant support, including that from prominent figures like former President Barack Obama, the Democrats successfully swayed voters in Virginia to adopt a plan perceived to disenfranchise Republican voters.
The April 21 referendum asked voters if the Virginia Constitution should be amended to permit the Legislature to temporarily create new House districts, aiming to ensure fairness in upcoming elections while maintaining standard redistricting processes post-2030 Census.
According to the Associated Press, around 97% of ballots were counted, with 51.5% voting in favor and 48.6% against—just over an 88,700 vote gap. Initial results on election day leaned towards “no” votes at 55%, with early voting contributing significantly to the “yes” votes.
Spanberger remarked that Virginians voiced their disapproval against a president who felt entitled to more Republican seats in Congress. “Virginia refused to comply with demands that other states have followed without voter input,” she asserted.
Virginia Senate Majority Leader Scott Surovell (D) criticized the “unprecedented gerrymandering” in sarcastic terms, claiming fairness and accountability prevailed. Meanwhile, former Governor Glenn Youngkin (R) denounced the new map as “unconstitutional” and thanked voters who opposed what he termed an “egregious power grab.” He urged the Virginia Supreme Court to annul this process that could disenfranchise many Virginians.
Legal challenges regarding the constitutionality of the amendment are now pending in the Virginia Supreme Court, with oral arguments scheduled for Monday.
