Alaska’s closely watched House race has finally been called, with Republican Nick Begich winning re-election. The result has angered some Democrats, who argue that a little-known candidate on the ballot may have affected the outcome.
Begich, who holds Alaska’s only seat in the U.S. House, finished with about 51.4% of the vote after ranked-choice tabulation. Bill Hill, an independent backed by the state Democratic Party, received nearly 48.7%.
Democrats have pointed to Eric Hafner, listed as the race’s Democratic candidate, as a possible spoiler. Hafner is incarcerated in New York and has never visited Alaska, according to reports.
Hafner received about 8% of first-choice votes, or 22,715 ballots—more than the final gap between Begich and Hill. Alexander Hutzler, writing for the progressive outlet Democracy Docket, argued that Hill might have won without Hafner in the race.
Democratic state Sen. Bill Wielechowski said voters around Alaska received an unsolicited text urging them to vote for Hafner. He also said Democrats spent significant resources trying to make clear that Hafner was a convicted felon.
Wielechowski suggested that a broader backlash against Republicans may have helped Hafner. Some voters, he said, may have simply selected the candidate listed as a Democrat without knowing who Hafner was.
Still, the ranked-choice results show that Hafner voters were much more likely to rank Hill second than Begich. About 45% of their votes transferred to Hill, compared with roughly 6% that went to Begich. Wielechowski said he hoped the matter would be investigated.
Ranked-choice voting has drawn criticism from conservatives, who say it can make ballots confusing and leave voters feeling their choices were not counted. In this race, Democrats are arguing that the system may have helped a Republican hold a seat they thought was within reach.
Hafner could not have served in Congress even if he had won, because his incarceration in New York prevents him from meeting Alaska’s residency requirement.
Alaskans also voted on whether to retain ranked-choice voting. The system survived, with about 54% voting to keep it and 46% voting against it.


