New trial date set in case involving Lindsay Clancy
Lindsay Clancy’s retrial over the deaths of her three children is scheduled to begin March 29, Judge William Sullivan said in court Monday.
Prosecutors have not yet specified which charges they will pursue. But prosecutor Jennifer Sprague said the case would require a jury, a comment Clancy’s defense took as a sign that prosecutors intend to retry her on first-degree murder charges. Less serious charges could potentially be heard by a judge alone.
“The die has been cast,” defense attorney Kevin Reddington said, suggesting the jury-trial requirement indicated the prosecution planned to proceed on the first-degree murder indictments.
Prosecutors said earlier this month that they wanted a new trial, though they had not clarified the charges at that point. The first trial ended in a deadlocked jury on September 4: one juror believed Clancy was guilty, while the other 11 did not believe she was guilty of murder.
At that trial, Reddington acknowledged that Clancy killed her children—5-year-old Cora, 3-year-old Dawson and 8-month-old Callan—in their Duxbury, Massachusetts, home in January 2023. Clancy pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder. Her defense argued she was not criminally responsible because she had been overmedicated and was experiencing postpartum psychosis.
Prosecutors countered that Clancy understood the difference between right and wrong and had planned the killings. They also argued that she arranged for her husband to leave the house that evening by asking him to pick up medicine for one of the children and dinner for the family.
Sullivan had previously urged both sides to prepare for a retrial in March, saying an earlier date might be possible but that March seemed more realistic. He is expected to reach the mandatory retirement age for Massachusetts judges later this year.
Reddington also pushed for a spring trial, saying he did not want Clancy to remain incarcerated for another year or longer while waiting for the case to proceed. Sprague said the retrial’s details would depend in part on the court’s decisions on pending motions.
The defense had asked the court to investigate the juror who opposed a guilty verdict and to dismiss the case, arguing that the judge had not adequately determined whether the juror followed the reasonable-doubt instructions. Sullivan rejected both requests, along with prosecutors’ request for a gag order ahead of a possible retrial.
Sullivan ruled that the jury’s deadlock made a mistrial necessary, so trying Clancy again on the murder indictments would not violate her protection against double jeopardy. Her defense team plans to appeal, but says the appeal will not delay the retrial.

