Livvy Dunne and Landry Kiffin join forces for a girls’ night out in NYC, the NCAA Punt of the Year, and a heartbreaking free throw

Livvy Dunne and Landry Kiffin join forces for a girls’ night out in NYC, the NCAA Punt of the Year, and a heartbreaking free throw

Readers respond to a recent Screencaps column

Several readers weighed in on an email from Don, a high school English teacher who had criticized a recent column. Mike, from West Lafayette, called Don’s message entertaining but insecure, and said its condescending tone reminded him of some English teachers he knew. Nate, from Minocqua, questioned Don’s claim that he wasn’t politically correct, while Matt pointed out that Don had confused “later” with “latter.”

John, an attorney, also took issue with the email’s tone and said Don seemed more interested in sounding impressive than making a convincing argument. Dave highlighted two language errors: Don had written “one that likes” when referring to a person, where “who” would be more appropriate, and had used “later” when he meant “latter.” Both readers found it ironic that an English teacher had made those mistakes while criticizing someone else’s writing.

Jim, who said he had taught university English and published work in academic and popular outlets, argued that Don’s criticism relied on logical fallacies. In Jim’s view, Don used Desmond Howard as an excuse to attack the columnist personally, rather than engaging with the original argument. Jim also questioned Don’s use of quotation marks and his description of readers as “aspiring sixteen year olds,” which he found unclear.

Chris said he had enjoyed the reader mail and was glad to see the latest round of criticism. Dan appeared to criticize the columnist’s replies to angry emails, saying they seemed careless and divisive—then revealed he was joking. He said the responses had been funny and agreed that some dog owners bring pets into places where they don’t belong. Dog-friendly patios are one thing, he wrote, but indoor restaurants and grocery aisles are another. He also took issue with people describing themselves as a dog’s “mom” or “dad.”

David said he had gone back to read an earlier column and now understood more of the Michigan–Ohio State rivalry. He agreed that Desmond Howard should not have criticized Jeremiah Smith, and said any college team would be fortunate to have Smith. He also suggested that some criticism of the column could be stated more plainly.

Tom B. said he enjoyed Don’s email and added that Washington football fans had little regard for Howard, whom he blamed for a disappointing first-round draft pick. Tom T. had a different complaint: a Medicare commercial airing during a college football game showed a talking dog joining a wife in berating her husband for not taking advantage of benefits. The absurdity made him laugh, he said, but he thought the portrayal of men in commercials had reached a new low.

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit
Telegram
WhatsApp

Related News