Police Critique Hochul’s Gun Violence Claims Following Officer Shooting

Long Island police expressed frustration after Governor Kathy Hochul touted progress against gun violence, just hours before an officer was shot in the face during a raid on a murder suspect’s home.

An unnamed 33-year-old Suffolk County officer was hit while authorities were executing a search warrant in North Bayshore on Thursday. This incident occurred right after Hochul participated in an event highlighting anti-crime efforts on the island.

“It’s ironic that the governor said crime was down just yesterday. Today, we have an officer shot,” remarked Suffolk PBA President Lou Sicherro.

Officer Civello voiced similar concerns, stating, “We’ve been facing these issues for years. Each time there’s a new solution, it seems there’s a new problem that gets overlooked.” His comments highlight a sense of ongoing struggles within the community.

Though he noted the recent changes to the Criminal Bail Act and Discovery Act as steps forward, there’s a sense that more significant reforms are necessary. Previously, these laws—modified under former Governor Andrew Cuomo in 2018—came under fire for enabling repeat offenders. Civello acknowledged some progress but insisted more action is needed.

At a recent event at the Suffolk County Police Academy, Hochul pointed to a 24% drop in murder rates from 2023 to 2024, and a 40% decrease from 2021 to 2024.

“I understand the challenges—every crime, every shooting, every murder takes a toll,” she remarked, while also conceding that the murder rate in Suffolk has seen a slight uptick in specific areas, calling it a minor issue statistically.

The officer who was shot has not been named, though sources say he is a naval veteran with three children.

Dr. James Voswinkel, of Stony Brook University Medical Center, detailed the injury, explaining that the bullet was perilously close to vital areas but, thankfully, is expected to fully recover.

The incident unfolded as officers were serving a search warrant for 48-year-old Nieves Reyes, who was taken into custody later that evening on charges of attempted murder and murder.

This situation has amplified calls from the PBA for greater support from Hochul, especially as Democratic governors prepare for reelection campaigns. Hochul is likely aware that perceptions of public safety will be crucial as she positions her record against previous crime criticisms from her 2022 campaign.