Louis CK Sells Historic Shelter Island Home
Louis CK has successfully sold his 123-year-old property in New York for $50,000 more than the original asking price.
He listed his Shelter Island residence, known as Primrose Cottage, for $4.3 million in early August and managed to find a buyer within just a month.
The final sale price reached $4.35 million, as reported.
The listing agents, Carl Gambino and Marco Maida of Compass Gambino Group, were not immediately available for comment.
CK acquired the two-acre property in 2014 for $2.44 million, making this sale a significant return on his investment. During his ownership, the 58-year-old comedian undertook considerable restoration efforts on the Tudor-style mansion, which included refurbishing the original mill and six fireplaces.
Primrose Cottage is steeped in history. Notably, it served as a vacation retreat for President Theodore Roosevelt and his successor, William McKinley. The site also reportedly hosted the unofficial U.S. debut of playwright J.M. Barrie’s “Peter Pan” and saw a summer visit from baseball legend Babe Ruth.
This 5,000-square-foot “cottage” comprises six bedrooms and five bathrooms. Listing details highlight its renovated chef’s kitchen, featuring checkered flooring, stainless steel appliances, and an updated butler’s pantry.
Built in 1901, the home dazzles with English charm showcased through beamed ceilings, a grand curved staircase, and a sunroom adorned with green latticework. CK also enhanced the outdoor space by adding a heated granite pool, hot tub, and a redesigned deep-water dock that can accommodate several boats.
The combination of historic appeal and modern amenities seems to have resonated well with buyers. On Shelter Island, properties typically remain on the market for a median of 137 days; surprisingly, CK’s home sold in just 18 days.
Currently, CK is on tour to promote his debut novel, “Ingram,” alongside his ongoing international comedy tour, “Ridiculous.”
